Bonellos New York Pizza serves hand-tossed pies with a thin, crispy crust, staying true to the style that made New York pizza famous. If you want to plan your next meal, this Bonellos New York Pizza Menu with Prices guide covers the pies, slices, sides, and drinks you will find at most locations.
Prices can shift a bit by city or franchise, so treat the numbers below as close estimates. Call your local shop to confirm before you order.
Bonellos New York Pizza Menu With Prices
The menu is built around classic pies and by-the-slice options. Here is what you can expect to pay.
Classic Pizzas
- Cheese Pizza (Large): $16.99
- Pepperoni Pizza (Large): $18.99
- Sausage Pizza (Large): $19.49
- Mushroom Pizza (Large): $18.99
- Veggie Supreme (Large): $21.99
- Meat Lovers (Large): $23.49
- Margherita (Large): $19.99
- White Pizza (Large): $20.49
Pizza By The Slice
- Cheese Slice: $3.75
- Pepperoni Slice: $4.25
- Sausage Slice: $4.50
- Specialty Slice: $5.25
Sides And Starters
- Garlic Knots (6): $5.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (6): $7.49
- Chicken Wings (8): $11.99
- French Fries: $4.49
- Side Salad: $5.99
- Caesar Salad: $7.99
Calzones And Strombolis
- Cheese Calzone: $10.99
- Sausage Calzone: $12.49
- Pepperoni Stromboli: $12.99
- Veggie Stromboli: $12.49
Drinks And Desserts
- Fountain Soda: $2.49
- Canned Soda: $1.99
- Bottled Water: $1.79
- Cannoli: $4.99
- Cheesecake Slice: $5.49
How To Order From Bonellos Without Wasting Money
You do not need to spend a lot to eat well here. A few simple moves keep your total low.
- Buy by the slice at lunch. Two slices and a drink usually cost less than $12.
- Order a large pie for groups. It feeds 3 to 4 people and beats buying slices one by one.
- Check for daily specials. Many shops run a two-slice and soda deal on weekdays.
- Skip delivery fees when you can. Pickup saves you $3 to $5 per order.
- Add garlic knots instead of wings. You get more food for less money.
What Affects The Prices On This Menu
Not every Bonellos charges the same. Keep these factors in mind.
- Location: City shops charge more than suburban ones.
- Toppings: Each extra topping adds about $1.50 to $2.50.
- Size: A medium pie costs roughly $3 less than a large.
- Taxes and fees: Delivery apps mark up menu prices by 15 to 20 percent.
Best Values On The Bonellos Menu
Top Picks Under $10
- Cheese slice and a soda
- Garlic knots
- Side salad with a slice
Top Picks For Sharing
- Large Meat Lovers pie
- Pepperoni Stromboli
- Wings and garlic knots combo
One large pie and two sides usually runs about $35 and feeds four people. That works out to under $9 per person, which is hard to beat for a full pizza dinner.
Quick Tips Before You Visit
- Call ahead on Friday and Saturday nights. Wait times can hit 40 minutes.
- Ask if the shop honors online coupon codes. Many do, even if they are not advertised.
- Check the crust option. Thin crust is the default, but you can request hand-tossed.
- Keep your receipt. Some locations offer a free slice on your next visit.
Use this Bonellos New York Pizza menu with prices as your starting point, then confirm with your local store. A quick phone call saves you surprises at the register and helps you build the best order for your budget.