Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern Menu with Prices is something many people look up before heading out the door, and for good reason. Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern brings back pub favorites, yet their updated price sheet surprises many returning fans. You might remember the old days of the Death by Chocolate cake or the classic Monte Cristo sandwich, but the current lineup has shifted a bit.
This guide breaks down the full menu with current pricing, so you know exactly what to expect when you sit down. We will cover appetizers, burgers, entrees, and even the drink specials that change by location.
Why The Bennigan’s Menu Has Changed Over Time
Bennigan’s has had a wild ride over the last two decades. The chain filed for bankruptcy back in 2008, which closed hundreds of stores. But the brand was revived, and now it operates under a different ownership group.
Because of that, the menu is not exactly what you remember from 2005. Some classics are gone, while others have returned with a modern twist. Prices have also gone up, just like everywhere else in the restaurant industry.
If you are looking for the exact Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern Menu with Prices, you should know that location matters. Franchise owners can set their own prices within a reasonable range. So a burger in Texas might cost a dollar more than the same burger in Ohio.
Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern Menu With Prices
Below is the most current breakdown of the standard menu items. These prices are based on the average of several corporate-owned locations. Your local tavern might have slight variations, but this gives you a solid ballpark figure.
Appetizers And Starters
You cannot start a meal at Bennigan’s without looking at the appetizer list. These are designed for sharing, but honestly, you might want to keep them to yourself.
- Classic Wings (6 pieces) – $9.99
- Classic Wings (12 pieces) – $16.99
- Boneless Wings (8 pieces) – $10.49
- Loaded Nachos – $11.99
- Spinach & Artichoke Dip – $9.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces) – $8.99
- Onion Ring Tower – $8.49
- Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese – $7.99
- Buffalo Chicken Dip – $10.29
The wings come in several sauces, including the signature “Bennigan’s Blazin'” sauce. That one has a serious kick, so be careful if you are sensitive to spice.
If you are watching your budget, the pretzel bites are the best value. They are filling and come with a generous portion of cheese sauce.
Burgers And Sandwiches
This is where Bennigan’s really shines. The burgers are cooked to order and come with a choice of fries, tots, or a side salad. The menu highlights the “World Famous” burgers, which have been around since the beginning.
- World Famous Burger – $12.99
- Bennigan’s Classic Burger – $11.49
- Mushroom Swiss Burger – $13.29
- Bacon Cheddar Burger – $13.49
- Southwest Burger – $13.99
- Monte Cristo Sandwich – $12.49
- Chicken Club Sandwich – $11.99
- Philly Cheesesteak – $12.99
- Fish & Chips Sandwich – $11.29
The Monte Cristo is the item that most people ask about. It is a ham and turkey sandwich that gets dipped in batter, fried, and then dusted with powdered sugar. It comes with a side of raspberry jam for dipping. It sounds weird, but it works.
You can add bacon to any burger for an extra $1.50. Adding avocado will cost you $1.99.
Entrees And Mains
If you want a full sit-down dinner, the entree section has several options. These are heavier meals that come with two sides unless noted otherwise.
- Fish & Chips – $14.99
- Chicken Tenders Platter – $12.49
- Grilled Salmon – $17.99
- Country Fried Steak – $14.29
- BBQ Ribs (Half Rack) – $15.99
- BBQ Ribs (Full Rack) – $19.99
- Chicken Fried Chicken – $13.99
- Steak & Fries – $18.49
The ribs are slow-cooked and slathered in a sweet bourbon BBQ sauce. They fall off the bone pretty easily. If you are really hungry, the full rack is a lot of food.
The steak and fries option is a decent deal for the price. It is a flat iron steak, which is not the most tender cut, but it has good flavor when cooked medium rare.
Salads And Soups
Bennigan’s does offer some lighter fare, even though the restaurant is known for heavy pub food. The salads are fresh and come in large portions.
- Caesar Salad – $9.99
- Grilled Chicken Caesar – $12.49
- House Salad – $8.99
- Cobb Salad – $12.99
- French Onion Soup (Cup) – $4.99
- French Onion Soup (Bowl) – $6.49
- Chili (Cup) – $5.29
You can add a grilled chicken breast to any salad for $3.99. The French onion soup is topped with a thick layer of melted provolone cheese, which is always a good thing.
Desserts
Do not skip dessert. The Death by Chocolate cake is legendary, and it is still on the menu. It is a massive slice of layered chocolate cake with fudge and chocolate chips.
- Death by Chocolate – $7.99
- Apple Crisp – $6.99
- Cheesecake of the Day – $6.49
- Brownie Sundae – $6.99
The Death by Chocolate is big enough for two people. Actually, it might be big enough for three people if you have already eaten a burger.
Kids Menu
If you have little ones, the kids menu offers smaller portions at lower prices. Each kids meal comes with a drink and a side.
- Kids Chicken Tenders – $6.49
- Kids Cheeseburger – $6.99
- Kids Grilled Cheese – $5.99
- Kids Mac & Cheese – $5.49
- Kids Fish Sticks – $6.29
Kids meals are available for children under the age of 10. The portions are actually pretty generous for a kids menu.
Drinks And Happy Hour Specials
Bennigan’s has a full bar, and they are known for their “Tavern” drinks. The happy hour specials are a big draw for the after-work crowd.
Most locations run happy hour from 3 PM to 7 PM on weekdays. During that time, you can get discounted appetizers and drink specials.
- Domestic Drafts – $3.99
- House Wine – $5.49
- Well Cocktails – $4.99
- Bennigan’s Iced Tea (Long Island) – $6.99
- Margarita of the Month – $5.99
The “Bennigan’s Iced Tea” is their take on a Long Island. It is strong, so pace yourself. The happy hour appetizer menu usually includes half-price nachos and wings.
How To Save Money At Bennigan’s
Eating out is expensive these days, but there are a few ways to keep the bill down at Bennigan’s. Here are some practical tips that work at most locations.
- Check the website for digital coupons before you go. Bennigan’s often runs a “buy one get one” deal on burgers during certain days of the week.
- Join the loyalty program. It is free, and you earn points on every dollar you spend. Those points turn into free appetizers or desserts.
- Go during happy hour. The discounted appetizers are almost a full meal by themselves.
- Skip the soft drinks and order water. A soda at a restaurant costs about $3.00 now, which is crazy.
- Look for the “Lunch Specials” menu. Many Bennigan’s locations offer a smaller lunch menu from 11 AM to 3 PM with lower prices.
If you are really hungry, consider the “Pick Two” lunch combo if it is available. You get a half sandwich and a cup of soup or salad for around $9.99. That is a solid deal.
What Is The Average Cost Per Person?
So, what should you expect to pay when you visit? Here is a rough breakdown based on the Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern Menu with Prices we listed above.
- Light lunch (soup and salad) – $12 to $15 per person
- Full dinner with an appetizer and entree – $25 to $35 per person
- Dinner with drinks and dessert – $40 to $50 per person
These numbers do not include tax or tip. If you are taking a family of four out for dinner, you should budget around $80 to $100 for a decent meal with non-alcoholic drinks.
It is not the cheapest option out there, but the portion sizes are large. You can easily take home leftovers and make a second meal out of them.
Location Differences And Pricing
One thing you need to understand about Bennigan’s is that it is not a massive national chain like Applebee’s or Chili’s. There are only about 30 locations in the United States right now. They are mostly in Texas, but you can also find them in a few other states.
Because the chain is small, there is less standardization. A franchise owner in one city might source ingredients from a local bakery, which changes the cost. So the prices we listed above are averages, not guarantees.
If you want the exact menu for your local store, you have two options. First, check the official website and use the “Locations” tool to find your store. Some locations have their own digital menu. Second, call the restaurant directly. The staff will happily tell you the current prices over the phone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Bennigan’s still have the Monte Cristo sandwich?
Yes, the Monte Cristo is still on the menu at most locations. It costs around $12.49 and comes with your choice of side. It is still fried, still dusted with powdered sugar, and still served with raspberry jam.
What are the happy hour days and times at Bennigan’s?
Most Bennigan’s locations run happy hour from 3 PM to 7 PM, Monday through Friday. Some locations also have late-night happy hour from 9 PM to close. You should call your local spot to confirm the exact times.
Is there a dress code at Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern?
No, there is no strict dress code. It is a casual pub atmosphere. You can wear jeans and a t-shirt without any issues. The restaurant is family-friendly during the day, but it gets more of a bar vibe at night.
Are there any gluten-free options on the menu?
Yes, there are a few options. The grilled salmon and the house salads can be prepared without gluten. You should tell your server about any allergies, and they will alert the kitchen. However, the fried items are not gluten-free because they share a fryer.
Does Bennigan’s offer takeout or delivery?
Yes, most locations offer takeout. You can call in your order and pick it up at the counter. Delivery is available through third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats, but the prices on those apps are usually higher than in-store prices.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
Bennigan’s is not trying to be a fine dining restaurant. It is a pub. The food is comfort food, the portions are big, and the prices are reasonable for what you get. The menu has changed over the years, but the core identity is still there.
If you are looking for a place to watch the game, grab a cold beer, and eat a solid burger, Bennigan’s still delivers. Just check the local menu before you go, because the prices and items can vary. And do not forget to save room for that Death by Chocolate cake. It is worth every penny.
So next time you are thinking about where to eat, keep this Bennigan’s Grill & Tavern Menu with Prices guide handy. It will help you plan your order and your budget. Whether you are a first-timer or a returning fan, there is something on the menu for you.