Bally Pizza keeps things simple with a menu built around classic pies, slices, and a few Italian staples. If you want the full Bally Pizza Menu with Prices, this guide breaks it down so you know what to order and what it costs before you go.
The menu is small on purpose. That means faster service and fewer surprises at the counter.
What You Need To Know Before You Order
Bally Pizza is a neighborhood spot, not a big chain. Prices can shift a bit by location, so treat the numbers below as a close guide.
Most people come for slices at lunch and full pies at dinner. Both are worth it.
Bally Pizza Menu With Prices
Here is how the menu is usually laid out. Sizes are typical for a standard shop.
Classic Pizzas
- Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Cheese Pie, 12 inch – $12.00
- Cheese Pie, 16 inch – $16.50
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Pepperoni Pie, 12 inch – $14.00
- Pepperoni Pie, 16 inch – $18.50
- Sausage and Onion Pie, 16 inch – $19.50
- Mushroom Pie, 16 inch – $18.00
Specialty Pies
- Margherita Pie, 14 inch – $16.00
- Meat Lovers Pie, 16 inch – $21.00
- Veggie Supreme Pie, 16 inch – $20.00
- White Pizza with Ricotta, 14 inch – $17.50
- Buffalo Chicken Pie, 16 inch – $21.50
Sides And Starters
- Garlic Knots, 6 pieces – $4.50
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $6.00
- Mozzarella Sticks, 5 pieces – $7.00
- French Fries – $3.50
- Chicken Wings, 6 pieces – $9.00
- Side Salad – $5.00
Calzones And Stromboli
- Cheese Calzone – $10.00
- Sausage Calzone – $12.00
- Stromboli – $12.50
- Veggie Calzone – $11.00
Drinks And Desserts
- Soda Can – $2.00
- Bottled Water – $1.75
- 2 Liter Soda – $4.00
- Cannoli – $4.50
- Tiramisu – $6.00
How To Order And Save Money
You do not need a big budget to eat well here. A few small moves keep the bill low.
- Go at lunch for slice deals. Two slices and a drink often cost less than a full pie.
- Split a 16 inch pie between two people. It is cheaper per person than two calzones.
- Skip delivery apps when you can. Pickup usually avoids extra fees.
- Ask about the daily special. Many shops drop the price on one pie each day.
- Order garlic knots instead of a second side. They fill you up for less.
Tips For First Time Visitors
If you have never been, keep your first order simple. A cheese slice tells you a lot about the kitchen.
Here is what regulars do:
- Order by the slice if you are eating alone.
- Call ahead for large pies on weekends. Wait times get long.
- Ask for the pizza well done if you like a crisp crust.
- Check the receipt. Prices at the counter can differ from the online menu.
Final Word On The Bally Pizza Menu
The menu covers the basics and does them right. Slices start near $3.50, pies run from about $12 to $21, and sides stay under $10.
Call your local Bally Pizza before you go. That way you get the current prices and no surprises.