Aurelio’s Pizza Menu with Prices has been a topic of conversation for families across the South Side of Chicago and Northwest Indiana for decades. If you are looking for the current cost of their famous thin crust, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down the full menu, from appetizers to desserts, so you know exactly what to expect when you order.
Since 1959, this family-owned chain has built a reputation on a specific style of pizza. The secret lies in their sweet sauce and the crispy, cracker-thin crust that holds up under a mountain of cheese. Prices vary slightly depending on whether you visit a corporate location or a franchise, but the figures below represent the standard current rates.
We have analyzed the official menu data to give you the most accurate breakdown possible. You will find that the cost of a meal here is slightly higher than national chains, but the portion sizes are generous. Let’s get straight to the numbers so you can plan your order without any surprises.
Aurelio’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Before we dive into the specific categories, it is important to understand how the pricing structure works. Unlike many pizzerias that charge per topping, Aurelio’s often prices their specialty pizzas as a complete unit. However, they also offer a “build your own” option that charges by the size and number of ingredients.
You will notice that the menu is split into two main sections: the regular menu and the “Famous Thin” menu. The thin crust is their signature, but they also offer a pan pizza and a stuffed pizza for those who want something heavier. Below is the full price list for their most popular items.
Appetizers And Starters
If you are not ready to commit to a full pizza, the starters are a solid choice. The portions are designed for sharing, though you might want to keep the garlic bread to yourself. Here are the current prices for the most common appetizers.
- Garlic Bread (4 pieces) – $5.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese (4 pieces) – $7.49
- Baked Ravioli (8 pieces) – $8.99
- Fried Mushrooms – $7.99
- Onion Rings – $6.99
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $9.99
- Chicken Wings (12 pieces) – $17.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces) – $8.49
- Buffalo Chicken Tenders (5 pieces) – $9.49
Most locations also offer a “Side Salad” for around $4.99. This is a simple mix of iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, and black olives. It is a good way to add some greens to a heavy pizza meal.
Specialty Pizzas (Famous Thin Crust)
This is the heart of the menu. The specialty pizzas come with pre-selected toppings that are known to work well together. You can order these in Small (12″), Medium (14″), Large (16″), or Jumbo (18″). The prices below reflect the Large size, which is the most popular for groups of three or four.
- The “Aurelio” (Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion) – $23.99
- Meatball Special (Meatball, Onion, Green Pepper) – $21.49
- Italian Sausage Special (Sausage, Onion, Green Pepper) – $21.49
- Deluxe (Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Bacon) – $25.99
- Shrimp Delight (Shrimp, Green Pepper, Onion) – $24.99
- BBQ Chicken (Grilled Chicken, BBQ Sauce, Red Onion) – $23.49
- Veggie Supreme (Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Tomato, Broccoli) – $22.99
If you want to build your own, the base price for a Large cheese pizza is $16.99. Each additional topping costs $2.25. Premium toppings like shrimp or extra cheese will run you $3.00 each. Be careful when adding multiple items because the price climbs quickly.
Pan Pizza Pricing
For those who prefer a thicker, doughier crust, the Pan Pizza is a different experience. It takes longer to bake, so expect a 30-40 minute wait if you order this. The pricing is slightly higher due to the increased dough weight.
- Small Pan Cheese (10″) – $12.99
- Medium Pan Cheese (12″) – $16.49
- Large Pan Cheese (14″) – $19.99
- Large Pan Deluxe (14″) – $26.99
The pan pizza has a buttery, fried bottom that is distinct from the thin crust. It is heavier and more filling. If you are ordering for two people, a Medium Pan is usually sufficient.
Stuffed Pizza Options
Stuffed pizza is a Chicago tradition, and Aurelio’s version is loaded with cheese. This is a meal that requires a fork and knife. The prices reflect the labor involved in making this two-crust creation.
- Small Stuffed Cheese (10″) – $14.99
- Medium Stuffed Cheese (12″) – $18.99
- Large Stuffed Cheese (14″) – $22.99
- Large Stuffed Deluxe (14″) – $29.99
Note that stuffed pizzas take approximately 45 minutes to prepare. You should call ahead if you are in a hurry. The serving size is deceptive; a Medium Stuffed can easily feed three people because it is so dense.
Pasta And Entrees
While pizza is the main attraction, the menu also includes a variety of pasta dishes. These are great for those in your group who do not want pizza. Most pasta entrees come with a side salad and garlic bread.
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $11.99
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $14.99
- Baked Mostaccioli – $12.99
- Cheese Ravioli – $12.49
- Chicken Parmesan (with pasta) – $15.99
- Eggplant Parmesan (with pasta) – $13.99
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $12.99
- Grilled Chicken Alfredo – $15.49
The pasta portions are large. You will likely have leftovers. The marinara sauce is the same sweet recipe used on the pizza, which gives the pasta a unique flavor profile that you do not find at Italian chains.
Sandwiches And Wraps
For a quicker lunch option, the sandwich menu offers several hot and cold choices. These are served on fresh bread and come with a pickle spear. You can add fries for an extra $2.49.
- Italian Beef (with giardiniera) – $10.99
- Meatball Sandwich – $9.99
- Sausage Sandwich – $9.49
- Chicken Parm Sandwich – $10.49
- Philly Cheese Steak – $11.49
- Turkey Club (Cold) – $9.99
- BLT (Cold) – $8.99
The Italian Beef is a local favorite. Make sure to ask for it “dipped” if you want the bread soaked in the beef juice. This is the authentic way to eat it in Chicago.
Salads And Soups
If you are looking for something lighter, the salad menu is more extensive than the simple side salad mentioned earlier. These are meal-sized portions.
- Chef Salad – $10.99
- Crispy Chicken Salad – $11.49
- Grilled Chicken Salad – $11.49
- Caesar Salad (with Chicken) – $10.99
- Greek Salad – $10.49
- Italian Salad – $9.99
The house Italian dressing is made in-house and is worth trying. It has a tangy vinegar base that cuts through the richness of the pizza cheese.
Desserts And Drinks
After a heavy meal, you might want something sweet. The dessert menu is limited but satisfying. They are known for their homemade apple cobbler.
- Apple Cobbler (a la mode) – $6.99
- Chocolate Cake – $5.99
- Cheesecake – $5.99
- Tiramisu – $6.49
- Bread Pudding – $5.49
For drinks, they offer standard sodas, iced tea, and lemonade. A large soft drink is around $2.99. They also have a selection of domestic and imported beers if you are dining in.
Pricing Variations And Deals
It is crucial to note that the prices listed above are for the standard menu. Many locations offer lunch specials on weekdays from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM. These specials often include a personal pizza and a drink for around $8.99.
You should also check for online coupons. The official website frequently has a “Buy One Get One Free” deal on large pizzas for carryout, but this excludes specialty pizzas. Also, they offer a 10% discount for senior citizens on Tuesdays at participating locations.
Delivery fees are separate. If you order through a third-party app like DoorDash or Grubhub, the prices will be marked up by 15-20%. It is always cheaper to order directly from the restaurant for pickup.
How To Order Efficiently
To get the best value for your money, you need to understand the sizing. Here is a quick guide to help you decide.
- For 1-2 people: Order a Small (12″) thin crust. You will have leftovers.
- For 3-4 people: Order a Large (16″) thin crust. This provides 8 slices.
- For 5+ people: Order a Jumbo (18″) or two Large pizzas.
- For parties: Consider ordering sheet pizzas, which are only available for carryout. A sheet pizza (approx. 18×26 inches) costs around $45.99 and feeds 10-12 people.
If you are ordering a specialty pizza, check if the location offers a “Tuesday Special.” Many stores offer a discount on large specialty pizzas on Tuesdays.
Gluten Free And Dietary Options
Aurelio’s does offer a gluten-free crust. However, it is not the same cracker-thin crust. It is a pre-made, denser crust that is baked separately. The price for a gluten-free pizza is higher.
- Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza (10″) – $14.99
- Gluten-Free Specialty Pizza (10″) – $19.99
They also have a vegan cheese substitute available upon request. This adds about $2.00 to the price. Be aware that the kitchen is not a dedicated gluten-free facility, so cross-contamination is possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the pricing and menu structure.
Does the price include tax?
No. The prices listed on the menu do not include sales tax. In Illinois and Indiana, the tax rate varies by municipality, so it is added at the register.
Why is the price different online vs. in-store?
Online ordering platforms often have a service fee built into the item price. The in-store menu is usually $1-$2 cheaper per item. Always call the store directly for the most accurate price.
Are there any discounts for large groups?
Yes, for orders over $100, you can often request a 10% discount by speaking to the manager. This is not advertised, but it is often granted for catering orders.
Is the “Aurelio” pizza the same as the Deluxe?
No. The “Aurelio” has five toppings. The Deluxe adds bacon and has a slightly higher price point.
Can I get a half-and-half pizza?
Yes, you can order a pizza with different toppings on each half. However, if you choose two different specialty pizzas, you will be charged the price of the higher-priced pizza plus $1.00.
To summarize, the Aurelio’s Pizza menu with prices reflects a premium product. You are paying for high-quality cheese and a sauce recipe that has not changed in over sixty years. While it might be tempting to compare prices to a discount chain, the flavor profile is entirely different.
When you are ready to order, look for the weekly specials on their social media pages. Many locations post a “Mystery Pizza” deal on Wednesdays where you get a random large specialty pizza for $14.99. This is a great way to try something new without spending a lot.
One last tip: the thin crust is best enjoyed fresh out of the oven. If you are getting delivery, expect the crust to soften slightly from the steam. To reheat leftovers, place them in a skillet on medium heat for 3-4 minutes to restore the crispiness. Do not use a microwave, as it will make the crust rubbery.
We hope this breakdown helps you navigate your next order. The prices are subject to change, so it is always wise to confirm with your local store before placing a large order. Enjoy your meal.