Dessert lovers searching for authentic Brooklyn-style sweets will find plenty to choose from at Aunt Butchies, from cannoli to cheesecake slices. The Aunt Butchies Desserts Menu with Prices gives you a clear look at what each treat costs, so you can plan your order before you arrive. This guide breaks down the menu by category, highlights popular picks, and helps you get the most value from every visit.
What Is Aunt Butchies Known For?
Aunt Butchies built its name on old-school Italian-American baking. The shop leans on family recipes, simple ingredients, and generous portions. If you grew up around a Brooklyn bakery, the flavors here will feel familar.
The dessert case changes a bit by season, but the core lineup stays the same. You will always find cannoli, cheesecake, cookies, and a few cakes by the slice.
Aunt Butchies Desserts Menu With Prices
Below is a typical price range for the dessert menu. Exact prices can vary by location and time of year, so treat these as a close guide.
Cannoli And Pastries
- Classic Cannoli (single) – $4.50
- Cannoli (half dozen) – $24.00
- Cannoli (dozen) – $45.00
- Chocolate Dipped Cannoli – $5.25
- Sfogliatella – $4.75
- Lobster Tail Pastry – $5.50
- Zeppole (seasonal) – $4.00
Cheesecake Slices
- New York Cheesecake Slice – $6.00
- Strawberry Cheesecake Slice – $6.50
- Chocolate Cheesecake Slice – $6.50
- Whole Cheesecake (8 inch) – $38.00
Cakes And Cupcakes
- Tiramisu Slice – $6.25
- Red Velvet Slice – $5.75
- Carrot Cake Slice – $5.75
- Cupcake (single) – $3.50
- Cupcake (half dozen) – $19.00
Cookies And Small Bites
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $2.50
- Rainbow Cookie – $3.00
- Pignoli Cookie – $3.25
- Biscotti – $2.75
- Cookie Tray (small) – $22.00
Drinks To Pair With Dessert
- Espresso – $3.00
- Cappuccino – $4.25
- Hot Coffee – $2.75
- Iced Coffee – $3.50
How To Order And Save Money
You can walk in and buy by the piece, or you can order trays for parties. Here is a simple way to keep your cost down.
- Buy cannoli by the dozen if you need more then eight. The per-piece price drops a lot.
- Pick up whole cheesecakes instead of slices when feeding a group of six or more.
- Ask about day-old pastry boxes. They often sell for half price in the late afternoon.
- Check the shop’s social page for holiday specials before you place a big order.
- Call ahead for large trays. Same-day walk-in orders may cost more.
What Regulars Usually Recommend
First-timers should start with the classic cannoli. The shell stays crisp and the filling is not too sweet. The New York cheesecake is another safe pick, with a dense texture and a thin graham crust.
If you like coffee flavor, get the tiramisu. If you want something to share, a cookie tray works well for offices and family gatherings.
Best Times To Visit
- Weekday mornings – shortest lines and fresh stock
- Friday afternoons – best chance for pastry deals
- Holiday weekends – order at least two days ahead
Final Tips Before You Go
Prices shift with the cost of butter, cream, and nuts, so a small change here and there is normal. Call the shop or check the online menu the same day you plan to visit. That way the Aunt Butchies Desserts Menu with Prices you see is the one you will actually pay.
Bring a cooler bag if you are driving far. Cannoli and cheesecake hold up better when they stay cold. And if you are not sure what to get, just ask the counter staff. They know which tray just came out of the kitchen.