Anthony’s Pizzeria Menu with Prices is something you will want to review before you call in that order. Anthony’s Pizzeria distinguishes itself through its Buffalo-style offerings, where the menu pricing on wings and pizza creates a complete game-day package. If you are looking for a place that takes its blue cheese seriously and knows how to handle a chicken wing, this is the spot for you.
You do not have to guess what you are going to pay when you get to the counter. The prices are listed clearly, and we have broken them down for you here so you can plan your meal without any surprises. Let’s look at what you can expect to spend on your next meal from Anthony’s.
Anthony’s Pizzeria Menu With Prices
We have gathered the standard pricing for the most popular items on the menu. Keep in mind that prices can change based on your specific location or if there is a special promotion running. It is always a good idea to call ahead and confirm the final total, but this guide will give you a solid baseline for budgeting.
Pizza Selection And Pricing
The pizza is the star of the show here. They offer a traditional round pie as well as a thicker, heartier Sicilian style. You can get cheese or pepperoni, but they also have specialty pies that are worth trying.
- Cheese Pizza (Medium): $12.99
- Cheese Pizza (Large): $15.99
- Pepperoni Pizza (Medium): $14.49
- Pepperoni Pizza (Large): $17.49
- Sicilian Cheese (Square Slice): $3.25
- Specialty Pizza (Large): $19.99 – $22.99
You can add extra toppings to any pizza for a small fee. Usually, this runs about $1.50 to $2.00 per topping depending on the size of the pie. If you are feeding a crowd, the large is the way to go because it offers the best value for your money.
Popular Specialty Pies
If you want to try something different, they have a few signature options. The Chicken Wing Pizza is a local favorite. It uses a ranch or blue cheese base, topped with diced chicken and a drizzle of hot sauce. The BBQ Chicken Pizza is also a solid pick if you want something on the sweeter side.
Buffalo Wings And Tenders
This is where Anthony’s really shines. The wings are fried to order and tossed in your choice of sauce. You can get them mild, medium, hot, or suicide if you are feeling brave. They also offer a garlic parmesan dry rub that is very popular.
- Wings (10 Pieces): $11.99
- Wings (20 Pieces): $21.99
- Wings (50 Pieces): $49.99
- Boneless Wings (10 Pieces): $10.49
- Chicken Tenders (3 Pieces): $6.99
- Chicken Tenders (5 Pieces): $9.99
All wing orders come with a side of celery and your choice of dipping sauce. You have to ask for extra blue cheese if you need more, and there might be a small upcharge for that. The ranch dressing is also house-made and goes great with the hot wings.
Subs, Sandwiches, And Wraps
If you are not in the mood for pizza or wings, they have a full lineup of hot and cold subs. The steak subs are made with real shaved steak, not chopped meat. The chicken finger sub is another classic choice that is very filling.
- Chicken Finger Sub: $8.99
- Steak & Cheese Sub (Small): $7.99
- Steak & Cheese Sub (Large): $10.99
- Italian Sausage Sub: $8.49
- Meatball Parm Sub: $8.49
- Veggie Wrap: $7.49
Most subs come with lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of dressing. If you want it “hotted up,” they will put some of their wing sauce on it for you. That is a great way to combine the best parts of the menu.
Dinners And Platters
For those who want a full meal, the dinner platters are a great option. These come with a side of pasta or fries. The portions are generous, so you might end up with leftovers for lunch the next day.
- Chicken Wing Dinner (10 Wings): $13.99
- Chicken Tender Dinner (5 Tenders): $11.99
- Fish Fry (Friday Only): $12.99
- Spaghetti with Meat Sauce: $9.99
- Baked Penne with Chicken: $11.49
These dinners are a solid deal because they include the side and a dinner salad. If you are really hungry, this is the route to take. The fish fry is particularly popular on Fridays during lent, so expect a wait if you go then.
Sides And Appetizers
You can round out your order with some classic sides. These are great for sharing with the table or just for snacking on while you wait for your main course.
- Garlic Knots (6 Pieces): $4.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese: $5.99
- French Fries (Large): $3.99
- Onion Rings: $5.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 Pieces): $6.49
- Side Salad: $4.49
The garlic knots are brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan. They come with a side of marinara sauce for dipping. It is hard to go wrong with these as a starter.
Beverages And Desserts
They have the standard soda fountain drinks available. You can also get bottled water or cans of soda to go. For dessert, the options are usually limited to a few classic items.
- 2-Liter Soda Bottle: $3.49
- 20 oz. Bottled Drink: $2.49
- Can of Soda: $1.29
- Brownie: $2.99
- Cannoli (1 Piece): $3.49
The cannoli is a nice way to end the meal if they have it available. Sometimes they sell out early, so you might want to order it with your main food items.
How To Order And Save Money
There are a few ways to make sure you get the best deal when you order from Anthony’s. They often run daily specials that are not listed on the main menu board. You have to ask about them or check their social media pages.
- Check for Lunch Specials: Many locations offer a smaller slice and a drink for a reduced price during weekday lunch hours.
- Ask about the Combo Deal: Sometimes you can get a pizza and a bucket of wings together for less than buying them separately.
- Call Your Order In: This saves you time and sometimes they offer a small discount for phone orders over delivery apps.
- Look for Coupon Books: They often advertise in local coupon mailers that get sent to homes.
Do not be afraid to ask the cashier if there are any current specials running. They are usually pretty upfront about it if you ask directly.
Delivery And Pickup Options
You can get your food delivered right to your door, but the delivery fee can add to the cost. If you live close by, picking it up yourself is always the cheaper option. They have a designated pickup area inside the store so you do not have to wait in line with the dine-in customers.
When you order for delivery, make sure you have the exact address and any delivery instructions ready. This helps the driver get to you faster and ensures your food arrives hot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the pricing and menu options at this restaurant.
Does Anthony’s Pizzeria offer gluten-free crust?
Some locations do offer a gluten-free crust option. It usually costs a few dollars more than the regular crust. You should call your local store to see if they have it in stock, as it can sell out quickly.
What is the price difference between mild and hot wings?
There is no price difference. The sauce choice does not affect the cost of the wings. You pay the same price whether you get mild, medium, hot, or suicide sauce.
Are there any vegetarian options on the menu?
Yes, you can get a cheese pizza or a veggie wrap. They also have a side salad and garlic bread that are suitable for vegetarians. You can also ask for a pizza with just vegetables as toppings.
Do they have a military or first responder discount?
Many locations do offer a discount for active military and first responders. You will need to show your ID at the time of purchase. It is best to ask when you place your order to see if it applies.
Can I order a half-baked pizza to cook at home?
Yes, this is a popular option. You can order a pizza that is not fully cooked so you can finish it in your own oven. This is great if you want a fresh pizza later in the evening. The price is the same as a regular pizza.
Final Thoughts On The Pricing
The Anthony’s Pizzeria menu with prices shows that you are getting a fair deal for the quality of the food. The portions are large and the ingredients taste fresh. It is not the cheapest pizza place in town, but you are paying for a better product.
When you are budgeting for a group, plan on spending about $10 to $15 per person. This will get you a slice or two of pizza and a drink. If you are adding wings to the order, you should budget a little bit more.
Remember that the prices listed here are a guide. The final cost might be slightly different at your local store. Taxes and any delivery fees will also be added to your total. Always double-check your receipt before you leave the counter to make sure everything is correct.
If you are planning a party or a large gathering, call ahead to ask about party trays. They can put together a platter of pizza and wings that is perfect for feeding a crowd. This is often more cost-effective than ordering several individual pies.
Go ahead and give them a call to place your order. You will be glad you did when you are eating those hot wings with a side of blue cheese. It is a simple pleasure that they do really well here.