Ordering at AJ Bagels goes smoother once you realize the breakfast sandwiches and deli spreads follow their own price tiers. This Aj Bagels Menu with Prices guide breaks down what you’ll pay for bagels, sandwiches, spreads, and drinks. Prices stay close to what you’d expect from a neighborhood shop, but a few items cost more than you might think.
Below is a simple walkthrough of the menu, organized by category. Use it to plan your order before you get to the counter.
Aj Bagels Menu With Prices
The menu splits into four main groups: bagels, spreads, sandwiches, and drinks. Each group has its own starting price, and add-ons push the total up fast. Here’s how it breaks down.
Fresh Bagels And Bialys
Bagels are the cheapest item on the menu, which makes them a easy starting point.
- Single bagel: $1.50
- Half dozen: $8.00
- Baker’s dozen (13): $15.00
- Bialy: $1.75
- Flagel (flat bagel): $1.75
Plain, sesame, poppy, and everything bagels all cost the same. Specialty options like asiago or cinnamon raisin sometimes run a quarter more.
Cream Cheese And Spreads
Spreads are where the price starts to climb. A plain bagel with cream cheese costs more then the bagel alone.
- Plain cream cheese (small tub): $3.50
- Flavored cream cheese (scallion, veggie, lox): $4.25
- Butter or jelly: $1.00
- Peanut butter: $1.50
- Whitefish salad (side): $6.50
- Tuna salad (side): $5.50
If you order a bagel with a flavored spread, expect to pay around $5.75 total. That’s the number most people forget when they budget for breakfast.
Breakfast Sandwiches
Breakfast sandwiches sit in the middle tier. They cost more than a bagel with spread but less than a full deli sandwich.
- Egg and cheese on a bagel: $5.50
- Egg, cheese, and bacon: $7.00
- Egg, cheese, and sausage: $7.00
- Egg, cheese, and ham: $7.25
- Bagel sandwich with avocado: $8.00
- Western omelet sandwich: $8.50
Add a second egg for $1.00. Add hash browns inside the sandwich for $1.50. These small extras add up if you order them every morning.
Deli Sandwiches And Lunch Items
Lunch items are the priciest part of the menu. Portions are bigger, so the jump makes sense.
- Turkey and cheese: $9.50
- Ham and swiss: $9.50
- Roast beef: $11.00
- Corned beef or pastrami: $12.50
- Tuna salad sandwich: $8.50
- Whitefish salad sandwich: $10.50
- BLT: $8.00
All deli sandwiches come on a bagel, roll, or sliced bread at no extra charge. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles are free. Cheese adds $1.00.
Drinks And Sides
Drinks follow standard cafe pricing. Nothing here will surprise you.
- Regular coffee (small): $2.25
- Regular coffee (large): $3.00
- Iced coffee: $3.50
- Latte or cappuccino: $4.75
- Orange juice: $3.25
- Bottled water: $2.00
- Soda can: $2.00
- Hash browns (side): $2.50
How To Order Without Overspending
A few small choices keep your total low. Try these steps:
- Pick a plain or everything bagel instead of a specialty one.
- Choose butter or jelly over flavored cream cheese.
- Skip the meat add-on if you just want eggs and cheese.
- Order the half dozen if you’re feeding two people.
- Get regular coffee instead of a latte.
A bagel with butter and a small coffee lands around $4.75. That’s the cheapest full breakfast on the menu.
What Affects The Final Price
Location matters. Shops in bigger cities charge a bit more than suburban ones. Tax also varies by state, so your total at the register will be higher then the menu price.
Some AJ Bagels locations run daily specials. A bagel and coffee combo often sells for $4.00 before 10 a.m. Ask at the counter, since not every shop advertises it.
Catering trays cost more upfront but less per person. A dozen bagels with two tubs of spread usually runs about $25.00.
Quick Summary
Bagels start at $1.50. Spreads add $1.00 to $4.25. Breakfast sandwiches run $5.50 to $8.50. Deli sandwiches go from $8.00 to $12.50. Drinks stay between $2.00 and $4.75.
Know these tiers before you order and the register total won’t catch you off guard.