If you are looking for a hearty Italian meal, Carollo’s menu splits between classic Italian entrees and pizzas, and prices vary depending on portion size. This guide to the Carollos Menu with Prices covers the main dishes, the average cost for each section, and how to order without spending too much.
Carollo’s is a family style spot. That means big plates. It also means the bill can climb fast if you are not careful. Below you will find the prices broken down by category, plus a few simple tips that help you save.
Carollos Menu With Prices
Prices at Carollo’s sit in the mid range for Italian food. A single diner can eat for around $18 to $25. A group sharing plates will pay more, but the cost per person usually drops. Keep in mind that prices differ by location, so treat the numbers below as a general guide.
Classic Italian Entrees
These are the core of the menu. Most entrees come in two sizes: a single portion and a family portion. The family size feeds three to four people and costs roughly double the single plate.
- Chicken Parmigiana: $19.95 single, $36.95 family
- Eggplant Parmigiana: $17.95 single, $32.95 family
- Fettuccine Alfredo: $16.95 single, $30.95 family
- Spaghetti and Meatballs: $17.50 single, $31.50 family
- Lasagna: $18.95 single, $34.95 family
- Chicken Marsala: $20.95 single, $38.95 family
Portion size is the main reason prices move up or down here. If you order the family tray, you pay less per plate. A single order is better if you are eating alone or want leftovers for one.
Pizza Prices
Carollo’s sells thin crust pizza by the slice and by the pie. The pie comes in three sizes. Toppings add a small charge each.
- Cheese slice: $4.25
- Cheese pie, small (12 inch): $13.95
- Cheese pie, medium (16 inch): $17.95
- Cheese pie, large (18 inch): $20.95
- Each extra topping: $2.00 small, $2.50 medium, $3.00 large
A large pie with two toppings lands near $27. That feeds two hungry adults or three light eaters. The slice is the cheapest way to try the pizza without committing to a full pie.
Appetizers And Sides
Starters are priced low, which makes them a good add on for a group. Sides are simple and cheap.
- Garlic Bread: $6.50
- Mozzarella Sticks: $8.95
- Fried Calamari: $11.95
- Side Salad: $5.50
- Side of Sausage: $4.95
Drinks And Desserts
Drinks are standard restaurant pricing. Desserts are worth sharing because the slices are large.
- Soda: $3.25
- Iced Tea: $3.25
- Coffee: $2.95
- Tiramisu: $8.50
- Cannoli: $5.95
How To Order Without Overspending
You do not need a coupon to keep the bill low. A few small choices make a big difference.
- Pick the family size if you have three or more people. The per person cost drops by about 30 percent.
- Order a large cheese pie and add one topping instead of two. You save a few dollars and still get flavor.
- Share an appetizer. The fried calamari is big enough for two or three people.
- Skip the soda and ask for water. That alone saves around $3 per person.
- Split a dessert. The tiramisu is rich and one order is enough for two forks.
What Affects The Final Price
Three things change what you pay at Carollo’s. First, the location. City stores charge more then suburban ones. Second, the time of day. Lunch specials often knock two or three dollars off an entree. Third, extras. Adding chicken to a pasta dish or extra cheese to a pizza raises the total fast.
Tax and tip are not included in the menu prices above. Plan for about 25 percent on top of your food total if you eat in the dining room. Takeout skips the tip, which makes it the cheaper option.
Now you know how the Carollos Menu with Prices breaks down. Entrees run $17 to $21 for a single plate. Pizza runs $14 to $21 for a pie. Use the tips above and you can feed a family for less than you think.