Carls Pizza bakes hand-tossed pies with generous toppings, and comparing menu prices across sizes helps you feed a crowd without overspending. This guide breaks down the Carls Pizza Menu with Prices so you know exactly what to expect before you order.
The menu stays simple on purpose. You pick a size, pick your toppings, and pay a fair price. Below you’ll find the full price list, size comparisons, and a few tips to save money on your next order.
Carls Pizza Menu With Prices
Prices vary a bit by location, but most shops follow the same basic structure. Here is what you can expect to pay.
Classic Pizzas
- Small (10 inch), cheese: $8.99
- Medium (12 inch), cheese: $11.49
- Large (14 inch), cheese: $13.99
- Extra Large (16 inch), cheese: $16.49
- Each extra topping: $1.25 small, $1.50 medium, $1.75 large, $2.00 extra large
Cheese is always the cheapest option. Loaded pizzas with five or six toppings can push a large pie past $22, so keep that in mind when you build your order.
Specialty Pizzas
Specialty pies come with set toppings, so the price is fixed no matter how many ingredients are on them.
- Meat Lovers, medium: $15.99
- Meat Lovers, large: $18.99
- Veggie Supreme, medium: $14.99
- Veggie Supreme, large: $17.49
- BBQ Chicken, medium: $15.49
- BBQ Chicken, large: $18.49
- Hawaiian, medium: $14.49
- Hawaiian, large: $16.99
Sides And Extras
- Garlic breadsticks: $5.49
- Cheesy bread: $6.99
- Chicken wings (8 piece): $9.99
- Chicken wings (12 piece): $13.99
- Caesar salad: $6.49
- Garden salad: $5.99
- 2 liter soda: $3.49
- Dipping sauce: $0.75 each
Drinks And Desserts
- Canned soda: $1.79
- Bottled water: $1.49
- Cinnamon sticks (5 piece): $4.99
- Chocolate chip cookies (3 piece): $3.99
How To Order Without Overspending
A few small choices can cut your bill by several dollars. Follow these steps the next time you order.
- Count your guests first. One large pie feeds about three adults, so two larges usually beat three mediums.
- Compare price per inch. A large costs about 25 percent more then a medium but gives you roughly 36 percent more pizza.
- Skip extra toppings on half the pie. Many shops charge per topping for the whole pizza, not per half.
- Watch for combo deals. A large pizza plus breadsticks often costs less then ordering them separately.
- Ask about pickup specials. Pickup orders are frequently $2 to $3 cheaper then delivery.
Size Comparison At A Glance
Here is a quick look at how the sizes stack up so you can pick the right one.
- Small: best for one person or a light lunch
- Medium: good for two people sharing
- Large: the sweet spot for families of three or four
- Extra large: ideal for parties and game nights
If you are feeding a group of six or more, two extra larges will cost less then four mediums and leave everyone full.
Ways To Save On Your Next Order
Carls Pizza runs regular promotions, and a little planning goes a long way.
- Check the website for weekly coupons before you call
- Order on weekdays, when many locations drop prices by a dollar or two
- Join the email list for a free side on your birthday month
- Buy gift cards during holiday sales, they often come with bonus credit
Prices do change, so confirm the current menu at your local shop before ordering. With the list above, you already know what a fair price looks like, and that makes it easy to spot a good deal when you see one.