Butter Maid Bakery has been satisfying sweet tooths for generations, and the Butter Maid Bakery Menu with Prices covers everything from donuts to custom cakes. If you live nearby or plan a visit, knowing what each item costs helps you budget before you walk in the door.
This guide breaks down the full menu by category. Prices are approximate and can change by location, so treat them as a helpful starting point.
Butter Maid Bakery Menu With Prices
The bakery keeps its lineup simple and classic. You will find fried donuts, pastries, cookies, breads, and made-to-order cakes. Below is a typical price range for each section.
Donuts And Fritters
- Glazed Donut — $1.25
- Chocolate Frosted Donut — $1.50
- Cinnamon Sugar Donut — $1.40
- Jelly-Filled Donut — $1.75
- Apple Fritter — $2.25
- Half Dozen Donuts — $7.50
- Dozen Donuts — $13.99
Donuts sell fast in the morning. If you want a full dozen, call ahead the day before.
Pastries And Breakfast Items
- Butter Croissant — $2.50
- Cinnamon Roll — $3.25
- Blueberry Muffin — $2.75
- Banana Nut Muffin — $2.75
- Cheese Danish — $3.00
- Sausage Roll — $3.50
These items pair well with coffee. Most shops brew a basic drip and a few flavored options.
Cookies And Bars
- Chocolate Chip Cookie — $1.50
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie — $1.50
- Peanut Butter Cookie — $1.50
- Brownie — $2.50
- Lemon Bar — $2.75
- Rice Krispie Treat — $2.00
Breads And Rolls
- White Bread Loaf — $4.50
- Wheat Bread Loaf — $4.75
- Rye Bread Loaf — $5.25
- Dinner Rolls (6 pack) — $3.99
- Hoagie Rolls (4 pack) — $3.50
Cakes And Custom Orders
Cakes are where prices move the most. A simple sheet cake starts low, while custom designs cost more based on size and detail.
- Single Layer Round Cake — $22.00
- 8-Inch Sheet Cake — $28.00
- Quarter Sheet Cake — $38.00
- Half Sheet Cake — $58.00
- Full Sheet Cake — $95.00
- Custom Birthday Cake — $45.00 and up
- Wedding Cake — $3.50 per slice and up
Custom Cake Deposit Rules
- Place your order at least 48 hours in advance.
- Pay a 50 percent deposit to lock in the date.
- Pay the balance at pickup.
- Bring your receipt if you change the design.
Custom work needs more lead time during holidays. Wedding cakes often need two to three weeks notice.
Coffee And Drinks
- Drip Coffee (small) — $1.75
- Drip Coffee (large) — $2.25
- Hot Tea — $1.50
- Hot Chocolate — $2.00
- Bottled Water — $1.25
- Orange Juice — $2.25
How To Order And Save Money
- Visit early for the best donut selection.
- Buy by the dozen to lower the per-item cost.
- Ask about day-old bread discounts.
- Sign up for the email list for seasonal deals.
- Order cakes ahead to avoid rush fees.
A dozen donuts costs less per donut than buying singles. Day-old bread usually sells at half price and still tastes fine for toast.
What Affects The Prices
Prices vary by location, season, and ingredient costs. Holiday weeks often add a small surcharge on custom cakes. Some shops charge extra for specialty fillings or fondant work.
Tax is not included in the prices above. Cash and card are both accepted at most locations, though a few small shops have a card minimum.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The Butter Maid Bakery menu stays affordable across the board. Donuts and cookies sit under three dollars, while cakes scale up with size and detail. Check with your local shop for the exact current prices before you order, since small changes happen through the year.