Every scoop at Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream is churned from a family recipe book that has been delighting taste buds since the mid-20th century. If you are looking for the Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down the full menu, current costs, and the best ways to save money on your next visit.
Handel’s is famous for using real fruit, premium chocolate, and a butterfat content that sits around 14%. That is higher than most commercial brands, which is why the texture is so thick and creamy. Before you head out, check the hours because many locations are seasonal.
Below you will find a clear breakdown of every item, from single scoops to the massive “Boss” size. We also cover sundaes, shakes, and the secret menu items that regulars swear by.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu With Prices
Prices can vary slightly depending on the state and franchise location. The costs below are based on average pricing from the 2024 season. You should always confirm with your local shop, but this gives you a solid ballpark figure for budgeting your trip.
Ice Cream Scoop Sizes And Prices
Handel’s offers four distinct cup sizes. Each size is a generous portion, and even the “Kids” scoop is larger than a standard scoop at other chains.
- Kids Scoop (4 oz): $3.49
- Single Scoop (6 oz): $4.29
- Double Scoop (8 oz): $5.79
- Triple Scoop (12 oz): $7.49
You can get any of these in a cake cone, waffle cone, or a cup. The waffle cones are made fresh in-store every morning. There is an extra charge for a waffle cone, usually around $0.99. The cake cone is free of charge.
If you are really hungry, ask for the “Boss” size. This is a massive 20-ounce serving that costs around $9.99. It is easily enough for two people, or one very dedicated ice cream fan.
Signature Sundaes And Splits
The sundae menu is where Handel’s gets creative. They do not skimp on toppings. Every sundae comes loaded with hot fudge, caramel, or fruit toppings, plus whipped cream and a cherry.
- Hot Fudge Sundae: $5.49
- Caramel Sundae: $5.49
- Strawberry Sundae: $5.49
- Pineapple Sundae: $5.49
- Banana Split: $7.99
- Brownie Sundae: $6.79
- Cookie Dough Sundae: $6.79
The Banana Split is a classic. It comes with three scoops of your choice, sliced bananas, and three different toppings. The Brownie Sundae features a warm, fudgy brownie base that pairs perfectly with cold ice cream.
Shakes, Malts, And Floats
Handel’s shakes are incredibly thick. They are blended with real ice cream, not a soft-serve mix. You might need to wait a minute for it to soften before you can use a straw.
- Classic Shake (16 oz): $5.99
- Large Shake (24 oz): $7.49
- Classic Malt (16 oz): $6.49
- Large Malt (24 oz): $7.99
- Root Beer Float: $5.49
- Coke Float: $5.49
You can choose any flavor of ice cream for your shake. The staff will blend it right in front of you. If you want a “turtle” shake, they will add caramel and pecans for an extra $1.00.
Handel’s Famous Ice Cream Cakes
Ice cream cakes are a big deal at Handel’s. They are custom made to order. You need to call at least 24 hours in advance. The cakes come in round and sheet sizes.
- 8-inch Round Cake (serves 8-10): $24.99
- 10-inch Round Cake (serves 12-14): $34.99
- Quarter Sheet (serves 16-20): $44.99
- Half Sheet (serves 30-36): $64.99
You can pick two flavors of ice cream for the layers. The middle layer is usually a crunchy chocolate or vanilla cookie crust. They also write personalized messages on top for birthdays. This service is free with any cake order.
Novelties And Take-Home Packs
If you want to enjoy Handel’s at home, they sell pre-packaged items. These are great for parties or just stocking your freezer.
- Ice Cream Sandwich: $3.99
- Chocolate Covered Bar: $3.49
- Pint (16 oz): $6.49
- Quart (32 oz): $10.99
- Half Gallon (64 oz): $14.99
The take-home pints are a good deal if you only want a single flavor. However, the quart and half-gallon options give you the best value per ounce. You can mix and match flavors in the larger sizes if you ask nicely.
Current Flavor Rotations And Limited Editions
Handel’s rotates flavors based on the season. They have over 100 recipes in their book, but only about 40 are available at any given time. You will always find the “Top 10” favorites, but the rest change monthly.
Year-Round Staples
These are the flavors that never leave the menu. They are the backbone of the brand and the most popular choices.
- Vanilla Bean: Uses real Madagascar vanilla beans
- Chocolate: Rich, dark, and creamy
- Strawberry: Made with real strawberry chunks
- Butter Pecan: Loaded with roasted pecans
- Mint Chocolate Chip: Uses Andes mints, not artificial flavoring
- Cookies and Cream: Packed with whole chocolate sandwich cookies
Seasonal And Monthly Specials
Every month, Handel’s releases a “Flavor of the Month.” These are often experimental or tied to holidays. For example, in October, you will see pumpkin pie and apple cider flavors. In December, they offer peppermint bark and eggnog.
Some past fan favorites include:
- Blueberry Cheesecake
- Coconut Cream Pie
- Peach
- Pistachio
- Black Cherry
You should always ask what the current special is when you walk in. Sometimes they have test flavors that are not listed on the board. These are usually sold at a discount because they are experimental.
How To Save Money On Handel’s Ice Cream
Ice cream is a treat, but the costs can add up if you have a family. There are several ways to cut down the price without sacrificing quality.
- Join the “Scoop Club”: Many locations offer a punch card. Buy 10 scoops, get one free.
- Check for Happy Hour: Some franchises offer a discount during slow afternoon hours, usually 2 PM to 4 PM.
- Buy the Half Gallon: If you eat ice cream often, the half gallon is the best value. It costs about the same as three single scoops.
- Skip the Waffle Cone: The cake cone is free. The waffle cone adds almost a dollar to your total.
- Share a Boss Size: The Boss size is cheaper than buying two separate double scoops.
Another tip is to follow your local Handel’s on social media. They often post flash sales or announce “Two-for-One” Tuesdays. These deals are not advertised nationally, so you have to be in the know.
Ordering Tips For First Timers
Walking up to a Handel’s counter can be a little overwhelming. The line moves fast, but you need to be ready. Here is how to make the process smooth.
First, decide on your container. Cup or cone? If you choose a cone, decide if you want cake or waffle. The waffle cone is worth the extra money if you like a sweet, crunchy texture.
Second, look at the flavor board before you reach the register. Do not wait until you are at the front of the line to start reading. The staff is friendly, but they want to keep the line moving.
Third, ask for a sample if you are unsure. Handel’s allows free samples of any flavor. They will give you a small spoonful on a tiny paddle. Try the “Flavor of the Month” before committing to a full scoop.
Finally, check your change and receipt. Sometimes they forget to add the free toppings you requested. It is always good to verify your order before you step away from the window.
Allergen And Dietary Information
Handel’s does not have a dedicated allergen-free kitchen. Cross-contamination is possible because they use shared equipment. If you have a severe allergy, you should be cautious.
However, they do offer some options for those with dietary restrictions.
- Sherbet: Usually available in orange or raspberry. This is dairy-free but contains sugar.
- No Sugar Added: They often have a vanilla or chocolate option that uses sugar substitutes.
- Gluten-Free Cones: Ask for a gluten-free cake cone. They are available at most locations.
Always inform the staff about your allergy. They will use a clean scoop and pull the ice cream from a fresh container in the back if possible. This minimizes the risk of cross-contact.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Handel’s ice cream more expensive than Baskin-Robbins?
Yes, Handel’s is generally priced higher. A single scoop is usually about $1.00 to $1.50 more expensive. However, the serving size is larger and the ingredient quality is higher.
Does Handel’s offer military or senior discounts?
Yes, many franchise locations offer a 10% discount to active military, veterans, and seniors over 65. You need to ask at the register, as it is not always advertised.
Can I order Handel’s ice cream online for delivery?
Some locations partner with DoorDash and UberEats. However, the prices on those apps are marked up by about 20%. You also have to pay delivery fees, so it is much cheaper to visit in person.
What is the most popular flavor at Handel’s?
The most popular flavor is typically “Vanilla Bean” or “Chocolate.” However, “Strawberry” is a huge seller because it contains whole, real strawberries. The “Blueberry Cheesecake” is also a cult favorite when it is in season.
Does Handel’s have a rewards app?
Handel’s does not have a single national rewards app. Each franchise operates independently. Some locations use a third-party app like “Loyalty” or “Punchh.” Ask your local store which system they use.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu with Prices is straightforward. You pay for quality, and you get a lot of it. The portions are generous, and the flavors are intense. A single scoop is often enough to satisfy even the strongest sweet tooth.
If you are watching your budget, stick to the kids size or buy a pint to take home. If you are celebrating something, splurge on a custom cake. The staff is always willing to help you pick the perfect flavor combination.
Remember that prices vary by location. A shop in California will charge more than one in Ohio due to overhead costs. Always call ahead if you are planning a large order or a party. They can prepare everything in advance so you do not have to wait in line.
Next time you pass by a Handel’s, do not hesitate. The line might look long, but it moves quickly. Grab a scoop of the monthly special and see why this family recipe book has stood the test of time. Your taste buds will thank you for the effort.