Blue Star Family Coney Island has fed generations of diners, and its prices remain part of the appeal. If you want the full Blue Star Family Coney Island Menu with Prices before you go, this guide breaks it down in plain terms.
You get classic coney dogs, burgers, breakfast plates, and Greek favorites. Most items stay cheap, and combos give you the best value.
What To Expect At Blue Star Family Coney Island
This is a old-school diner setup. You order at the counter or from a server, and food comes out fast.
Portions are fair for the price. Cash and cards both work at most locations, but bring a little cash just in case.
Breakfast Menu And Prices
Breakfast runs early and stays affordable. Here are common picks:
- Two Eggs with Toast and Potatoes: $5.99
- Egg and Cheese Sandwich: $3.49
- Bacon or Sausage Add-On: $2.29
- Short Stack Pancakes: $5.49
- Full Stack Pancakes: $6.99
- Oatmeal with Toast: $4.29
- Coffee: $1.99
- Orange Juice (small): $2.49
Best Breakfast Value
The two-egg plate is the cheapest full meal on the menu. Add coffee and you are still under $9.
Coney Dogs And Sandwiches
The coney dog is the reason most people walk in. It is still one of the best deals in the city.
- Coney Dog: $2.79
- Coney Dog with Cheese: $3.29
- Two Coney Dogs: $5.29
- Loose Hamburger: $4.49
- Chili Cheese Fries: $4.99
- Fish Sandwich: $4.99
- Grilled Cheese: $3.29
- BLT Sandwich: $4.79
Burgers And Combos
Burgers come plain or loaded. Combos add fries and a drink for a small upcharge.
- Hamburger: $3.99
- Cheeseburger: $4.49
- Double Cheeseburger: $6.49
- Burger Combo with Fries and Drink: $7.99
- Chicken Sandwich: $5.29
- Chicken Strip Basket: $7.49
The combo is the smart order if you are hungry. You save about $1.50 versus buying each item alone.
Greek And Dinner Favorites
Blue Star also serves Greek dishes that regulars order again and again.
- Gyro Sandwich: $6.49
- Chicken Gyro: $6.99
- Greek Salad: $6.99
- Greek Salad with Chicken: $8.49
- Spinach Pie: $3.99
- Saganaki: $5.99
- Half Chicken Dinner: $9.99
- Liver and Onions: $8.99
Sides, Drinks, And Desserts
Sides are cheap, so you can build a bigger meal without spending much more.
- French Fries: $2.49
- Onion Rings: $3.49
- Cole Slaw: $1.99
- Soft Drink: $1.99
- Milkshake: $3.99
- Rice Pudding: $2.99
- Slice of Pie: $3.49
Blue Star Family Coney Island Menu With Prices: Money-Saving Tips
You do not need to spend much to eat well here. Use these tips to keep your bill low.
- Order the two coney dogs instead of one combo. It costs less and fills you up.
- Pick the burger combo over a la carte items.
- Drink water instead of soda to save about $2 per person.
- Go for breakfast, where the full plates are the cheapest on the menu.
- Split a large fries with a friend.
Do Prices Change By Location
Yes, they can. Different Blue Star locations may charge a bit more or less.
Franchise spots near downtown areas often run 25 to 50 cents higher per item. Suburban spots tend to stay closer to the prices listed here.
Call ahead if you need exact numbers. Menus also change with seasons and food costs.
Final Word On The Menu
Blue Star keeps it simple and cheap. A full meal for one person usually lands between $8 and $12.
That is why families keep coming back. You get real food, fast service, and a bill that does not hurt.