Bay Goodman Pizza Fairport serves slices and pies with prices listed clearly, so you know exactly what your pizza night costs. If you want the full Bay Goodman Pizza Fairport Menu with Prices before you order, this guide breaks it down in simple terms.
The shop keeps things straightforward. You pick a size, pick your toppings, and pay a fair price. No surprises at the counter.
Bay Goodman Pizza Fairport Menu With Prices
Prices can shift a little over time, and specials change by the week. Use the numbers below as a close guide, then call ahead to confirm.
Pizza Sizes And Base Prices
- Personal 10 inch cheese pizza: about $9.99
- Small 12 inch cheese pizza: about $12.99
- Medium 14 inch cheese pizza: about $15.99
- Large 16 inch cheese pizza: about $18.99
- Sicilian square, thick crust: about $21.99
Each extra topping runs about $1.50 to $2.50 depending on the size. Premium items like sausage or extra cheese sit at the higher end.
Specialty Pies
- Pepperoni Lovers: $17.99 small, $21.99 large
- Meat Lovers: $20.99 small, $25.99 large
- Veggie Garden: $18.99 small, $23.99 large
- Buffalo Chicken: $19.99 small, $24.99 large
- White Garlic Pizza: $18.49 small, $22.99 large
Slices And Quick Bites
- Cheese slice: $3.50
- Pepperoni slice: $4.00
- Two slice combo with soda: $8.50
- Garlic knots, six piece: $5.99
- Garlic bread with cheese: $7.49
Sides And Salads
- Garden salad: $6.99
- Caesar salad: $7.99
- Antipasto salad: $9.99
- Chicken wings, eight piece: $11.99
- Mozzarella sticks, six piece: $7.99
- French fries: $3.99
Drinks And Desserts
- Fountain soda: $2.25
- Bottled water: $1.75
- 2 liter soda: $3.99
- Cannoli: $4.50
- Cheesecake slice: $5.99
Deals And Combos
Weeknight deals are the best way to save. Most run Monday through Thursday.
- Two large cheese pizzas: about $29.99
- Large pizza plus wings: about $27.99
- Family meal, two pizzas, salad, and soda: about $39.99
- Lunch slice and drink special: about $6.99
Ask about the current deal when you call. Staff are happy to tell you what is running that day.
How To Order Without Overspending
A few small habits keep your total low.
- Order a large instead of two mediums. The price per slice is better.
- Skip bottled drinks and grab a 2 liter if you are feeding a group.
- Check the combo deals before building your own order.
- Pick up instead of delivery to avoid the fee.
- Split a specialty pie with a plain cheese pizza for balance.
Delivery, Pickup, And Extra Fees
Pickup is always the cheapest option. Delivery usually adds a fee of about $3 to $5, plus a tip.
Most orders are ready in 20 to 30 minutes. Large catering orders need more notice, so call a day ahead if you need a big batch.
Tax And Tips
New York sales tax applies to your total. Budget about 8 percent on top of the menu price. For delivery, a tip of $3 to $5 is standard.
What Regulars Say About The Value
Locals in Fairport tend to agree on a few points. The crust holds up well. The sauce is not too sweet. Portions match the price.
If you are feeding four people, one large specialty pie and one large cheese pizza usually does it. That lands around $45 before tax, which is fair for the area.
Final Word On The Menu
The menu is simple, the pricing is clear, and you can feed a family without going over budget. Call the Fairport shop to confirm today’s prices and deals before you order. A quick call saves you money and time.