Amish-style cooking draws crowds because the menu relies on recipes passed down through generations of family kitchens. If you are planning a visit, you likely want to see the Der Dutchman Menu with Prices before you go. This guide breaks down the full offerings, from breakfast to dinner, so you know exactly what to expect and what it will cost.
Der Dutchman is a staple in Ohio for homestyle comfort food. Located in Plain City, this restaurant serves family-style meals and a massive bakery that smells like fresh pie. Knowing the current prices helps you budget for a hearty meal that will likely fill you up for the rest of the day.
Let’s look at the real costs, portion sizes, and the best items to order. We will cover the daily specials, the famous broasted chicken, and the soup and salad bar.
Der Dutchman Menu With Prices
The menu is extensive, but it centers around classic American fare. You will find everything from liver and onions to country fried steak. Prices change occasionally, but these figures reflect the most recent published menu data.
Below is a breakdown of the main categories. Remember that sides like mashed potatoes and dressing usually come with the entrees. The portions are generous, so consider sharing if you have a smaller appetite.
Breakfast Offerings And Costs
Breakfast is served all day on certain days, but it is primarily a morning affair. The breakfast menu features eggs cooked to order, pancakes, and their signature sausage gravy.
- Two eggs, toast, and home fries: $8.99
- Buttermilk pancakes (short stack): $6.49
- Full stack with sausage or bacon: $9.79
- Amish Breakfast (eggs, meat, potatoes, and biscuit): $10.29
- Omelets (cheese, western, or veggie): $9.99 to $11.49
- French toast with syrup: $8.29
You can add a side of scrapple for $3.49. That is a local favorite that many visitors try for the first time. The coffee is bottomless and costs around $2.79 per cup.
If you go on a weekday before 11 AM, you might catch a senior discount. Ask your server about the current specials because they change weekly.
Lunch And Dinner Entrees
The dinner menu is where Der Dutchman shines. Most entrees come with a trip to the soup and salad bar. This bar is famous for its creamy potato soup and chow chow.
Here are the standard prices for the main dishes:
- Broasted Chicken (half bird): $12.99
- Country Fried Steak with gravy: $13.49
- Roast Turkey with dressing: $12.79
- Baked Ham with pineapple glaze: $12.49
- Meatloaf with ketchup glaze: $11.99
- Grilled Pork Chops (two): $15.29
- Liver and Onions: $11.49
- Fried Shrimp (hand-breaded): $14.99
Each platter includes your choice of two sides. Standard sides include mashed potatoes, noodles, green beans, corn, applesauce, and cottage cheese. You can swap out a side for a baked potato for a small upcharge.
The “Broasted” chicken is the top seller. It is pressure-fried, which keeps the meat juicy while the skin gets crispy. You will not find a better version at a chain restaurant.
Family Style Dining Option
If you are with a group, the family style dinner is a great value. This option brings large bowls of food to your table so everyone can pass them around. It includes fried chicken, roast beef, mashed potatoes, dressing, noodles, and vegetables.
The price for family style is $19.99 per adult. Children aged 4-12 eat for $8.99. Kids under 3 are free. This is a fixed price, so you do not need to calculate individual entrees.
This is the best way to taste multiple proteins. The roast beef is slow-cooked and falls apart with a fork. The mashed potatoes are real, not from a box.
Soup And Salad Bar Details
You can visit the soup and salad bar alone without ordering an entree. This is a popular lunch choice for lighter eaters. The bar features fresh greens, pasta salads, fruit, and cheese.
- Soup and Salad Bar only (lunch): $10.99
- Soup and Salad Bar only (dinner): $12.49
- Add a bowl of chicken noodle soup: $2.00 extra
The soup rotation includes chicken and noodles, vegetable beef, and cream of broccoli. The bar also has homemade croutons and several types of dressing. Do not skip the peanut butter spread that comes with the bread basket.
If you are gluten sensitive, the salad bar is a safe bet. Just ask for the ingredients list to avoid any hidden flour in the pasta salads.
Sandwiches And Handhelds
For a quicker meal, the sandwich section offers generous portions. These come with a side of chips or a small salad.
- Reuben with corned beef: $10.49
- Club Sandwich (triple decker): $9.99
- Grilled Cheese with tomato: $6.79
- Chicken Salad Croissant: $8.99
- Philly Cheesesteak: $11.29
The Reuben is piled high with sauerkraut and thousand island dressing. The bread is grilled in butter, giving it a golden crunch. You can add a cup of soup to any sandwich for $2.50.
Desserts And Bakery Prices
The bakery is a destination on its own. You walk in through the gift shop, and the display cases are full of pies, cookies, and donuts. The prices are very reasonable compared to city bakeries.
- Whole cream pie (coconut, chocolate, banana): $11.99
- Slice of pie (in restaurant): $3.79
- Fried pies (apple or peach): $2.49 each
- Donuts (yeast or cake): $1.29 each
- Loaf of Amish bread: $4.99
- Whoopie pies: $3.29
The shoo-fly pie is a molasses-based treat that is a regional specialty. If you have never had it, order a slice with coffee. It is sweet but not overpowering.
You can order whole pies to take home. They freeze well, so you can stock up for the holidays. The bakery also sells jams, jellies, and bulk spices.
Beverages And Drinks
Drink prices are standard for a family restaurant. You will pay for refills on soft drinks, but coffee and tea are usually bottomless.
- Soft drinks (Coke, Sprite, etc.): $2.99
- Iced Tea (unsweetened or sweet): $2.79
- Fresh squeezed lemonade: $3.49
- Milk (white or chocolate): $2.49
- Hot tea: $2.49
They also offer a selection of local craft sodas from a nearby bottling company. These are fun to try if you want something different. The root beer is creamy and has a strong sassafras flavor.
Daily Specials And Value Deals
Der Dutchman runs daily specials that are not always on the printed menu. These are posted on the board near the entrance. You can often get a full meal for under $10 on weekdays.
- Monday: Meatloaf special with soup and salad bar
- Tuesday: Taco salad or chicken fried steak
- Wednesday: Broasted chicken special
- Thursday: Roast turkey dinner
- Friday: Fish fry (cod or perch)
These specials usually range from $8.99 to $12.99. They include the soup and salad bar, which makes them a steal. Check the restaurant’s Facebook page for the weekly schedule before you go.
There is also a “Senior Plate” available for guests over 60. This offers smaller portions at a reduced price. You can get a senior portion of most entrees for about $2 less than the regular price.
Kid’s Menu And Portions
Children have their own menu with smaller prices. The portions are still generous for little ones. Each kids meal comes with a drink and a small dessert.
- Chicken tender basket: $5.99
- Macaroni and cheese: $4.99
- Mini cheeseburger with fries: $5.49
- Grilled cheese with fruit cup: $4.79
- Spaghetti with meat sauce: $5.29
Kids meals come on a plastic plate with a compartment for the side. The staff is very accommodating if you need to swap out a side for something your child will actually eat.
Gluten Free And Dietary Options
While the menu is heavy on carbs, there are options for restricted diets. The broasted chicken is not gluten free due to the breading. However, the grilled pork chops and the baked ham are safe choices.
You can request a plain baked potato instead of the mashed potatoes. The green beans are cooked with ham, so ask for them without the meat if you are vegetarian. The salad bar is the easiest way to build a compliant meal.
There is no dedicated gluten free fryer, so do not order the fries if you have celiac disease. The staff is knowledgeable and will walk you through the options.
Tips For Ordering And Saving Money
To get the best experience, follow these simple steps:
- Arrive before 11:30 AM for lunch to avoid the rush.
- Order the broasted chicken if it is your first visit.
- Skip the appetizer; the bread basket and salad bar are filling.
- Ask about the daily special before you look at the menu.
- Split an entree with a friend; the portions are huge.
- Buy a whole pie from the bakery on your way out.
If you are on a budget, the soup and salad bar alone is the best value. You can fill up on fresh items and warm soup without spending more than $12. The bread basket is included with the bar, so you will not leave hungry.
Another tip is to check for coupons in the local tourism guides. Many hotels in the Plain City area have flyers for a free dessert or a percentage off your meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the current prices at Der Dutchman?
Most entrees range from $11.99 to $15.29. The family style dinner is $19.99 per adult. Breakfast items are generally under $10. Prices do change, so call ahead to confirm.
Does Der Dutchman have a salad bar?
Yes, the soup and salad bar is included with most lunch and dinner entrees. You can also order it alone for around $11 to $12 depending on the time of day.
Is the broasted chicken worth the price?
Yes, it is the most popular item on the menu. The pressure frying method makes the skin crispy without drying out the meat. A half bird costs about $12.99 and includes two sides.
Can you buy pies to take home?
Absolutely. The bakery sells whole pies for about $11.99. You can order them by the slice in the restaurant. They also sell frozen pies to bake at home later.
Are there discounts for seniors or children?
Seniors over 60 can order a smaller portion at a reduced price. Children aged 4-12 have a dedicated menu with items under $6. Kids under 3 eat free from the family style menu.
Final Thoughts On Visiting
Der Dutchman offers a filling meal at a fair price. The food is consistent, and the service is fast even when the restaurant is packed. You should plan to spend about $15 to $20 per person for dinner with a drink and dessert.
The atmosphere is casual and family friendly. You will see large groups celebrating birthdays and church gatherings. The staff moves quickly, so you will not wait long for refills or your check.
If you have never been to an Amish restaurant, this is a good introduction. The portions are large, the flavors are simple, and the hospitality is warm. Bring a big appetite and a container for leftovers.
Remember that the menu is subject to change with the seasons. The restaurant also offers a “To Go” menu where you can order family meals for pickup. These are great for feeding a crowd at home without cooking.
Check the hours before you go, as they close early on Sundays. The restaurant is usually closed on major holidays. A quick phone call can save you from a wasted trip.
Now you have a clear picture of the Der Dutchman Menu with Prices. Use this guide to order confidently and enjoy a taste of Amish country cooking.