Sub shops that started in Rochester know that the quality of their bread determines whether customers return for another visit. That is why so many people still ask about the DiBella’s Subs Menu with Prices before they walk in the door. You want fresh rolls, quality meats, and a price that does not make you wince.
DiBella’s has grown from a single location in 1918 to a regional favorite across several states. The menu looks simple, but there are layers of choices, sizes, and add-ons that can change your total cost. Let’s break down exactly what you will pay, what you should order, and how to keep your bill reasonable.
DiBella’s Subs Menu With Prices
DiBella’s keeps their pricing structure fairly consistent across locations, but you should expect small differences based on your city or state. The company does not publish a single national price list. However, the ranges below reflect current averages from multiple store locations in New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and other states.
You have three main size options for most subs: Small (6 inches), Regular (12 inches), and Giant (18 inches). The price jumps are not always linear, so the Regular size often gives you the best value per ounce.
Classic Cold Subs
These are the subs that made DiBella’s famous. They use Boar’s Head meats and cheeses, which explains why the prices sit a little higher than your average corner deli.
- **The DiBella (Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Oil)** – Small: $8.49, Regular: $11.99, Giant: $15.99
- **Turkey Breast** – Small: $8.99, Regular: $12.49, Giant: $16.49
- **Roast Beef** – Small: $9.49, Regular: $13.49, Giant: $17.99
- **Ham & Provolone** – Small: $8.49, Regular: $11.99, Giant: $15.99
- **Tuna Salad** – Small: $8.99, Regular: $12.49, Giant: $16.49
- **Chicken Salad** – Small: $8.99, Regular: $12.49, Giant: $16.49
- **BLT** – Small: $8.49, Regular: $11.99, Giant: $15.99
- **Vegetarian** – Small: $7.99, Regular: $10.99, Giant: $14.49
Every cold sub comes with your choice of fresh bread. The seeded roll is the classic option. You can also pick a wrap or a bowl if you are cutting carbs, but those options cost the same as the sub.
Hot Subs And Melts
Hot subs take a few extra minutes because they toast the bread and melt the cheese. The prices reflect the extra preparation time and the quality of the cooked meats.
- **Meatball Parmesan** – Small: $8.99, Regular: $12.99, Giant: $16.99
- **Chicken Parmesan** – Small: $9.49, Regular: $13.49, Giant: $17.99
- **Steak & Cheese** – Small: $9.99, Regular: $14.49, Giant: $18.99
- **Philly Cheesesteak** – Small: $10.49, Regular: $14.99, Giant: $19.49
- **Turkey Bacon Melt** – Small: $9.49, Regular: $13.49, Giant: $17.99
- **Pastrami Reuben** – Small: $9.99, Regular: $14.49, Giant: $18.99
The hot subs come with melted provolone or American cheese unless you request something else. You can add peppers, mushrooms, or extra cheese for a small upcharge.
Build Your Own Sub
If you do not see exactly what you want, you can build your own. This is where the price can creep up if you are not careful. The base price for a custom cold sub starts at the same level as the classic options. Each extra meat adds about $1.50 to $2.00. Extra cheese adds about $1.00.
- Pick your bread: white, wheat, rye, or wrap
- Choose your size: Small, Regular, or Giant
- Select one meat or cheese included in the base price
- Add additional meats or cheeses for a per-item charge
- Load up on free veggies: lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, banana peppers
- Choose your dressing: oil, vinegar, mayo, mustard, or their house dressing
Most people end up paying between $9.00 and $12.00 for a custom Regular sub. That is reasonable for the portion size and the Boar’s Head quality.
Extras, Sides, And Add-Ons
The sub is the main event, but you will probably want a side or a drink to complete the meal. These prices are fairly standard across the chain.
Bags Of Chips
- Regular chip bag (Lay’s, Doritos, Ruffles): $1.79
- Large chip bag: $2.49
Cookies And Brownies
- Chocolate chip cookie: $1.49
- Double chocolate cookie: $1.49
- Oatmeal raisin cookie: $1.49
- Brownie: $2.29
Drinks
- Bottled water: $2.29
- Canned soda: $1.99
- Fountain drink (regular): $2.49
- Fountain drink (large): $2.89
- Bottled iced tea: $2.79
You can also order a pickle spear for $0.89 or a side of coleslaw for $1.99. These small additions do not break the bank.
Meal Deals And Combos
DiBella’s does not run a traditional combo menu like some fast food places. However, they do offer a few ways to save if you are feeding more than one person.
The Party Sub
If you are feeding a group, the party sub is the best value. You can order a half tray or a full tray. A half tray feeds about 5 to 7 people and costs between $35.00 and $45.00 depending on the meat selection. A full tray feeds 10 to 14 people and runs between $60.00 and $80.00.
The party sub comes on a long roll cut into individual portions. You choose the meats, cheeses, and toppings. They do not charge extra for the party tray packaging.
Frequent Eater Card
Ask about the frequent eater card at the register. You get a stamp for every sub you purchase. After ten stamps, you get a free Regular sub. This is not a formal rewards program, but it works at most corporate and franchise locations.
Some locations also run a daily special. For example, Tuesday might be $1.00 off any Regular sub. Friday might be a free cookie with a Giant sub purchase. These deals vary by store, so it is worth asking when you walk in.
How To Save Money On Your Order
You do not have to spend a fortune to eat well at DiBella’s. Here are some practical ways to keep your total down.
- **Skip the Giant size** – The Regular is usually enough for two meals or one very hungry person. The Giant costs almost 50% more but only gives you 50% more bread and meat.
- **Share a party sub** – If you are with three or more people, split a half tray. It works out cheaper per person than ordering individual subs.
- **Drink water** – Fountain drinks cost almost three dollars. Water is free from the tap, or you can bring your own bottle.
- **Use the free veggies** – Load up on banana peppers, onions, lettuce, and tomatoes. These are free and add bulk without extra cost.
- **Check for coupons** – DiBella’s occasionally sends out coupons through their email list. Sign up on their website before you go.
You can also order just a half sub if you are not very hungry. Some locations will sell you a half portion of a cold sub at about 60% of the Small price. This is not on the printed menu, but it is worth asking for.
Ordering Tips For First-Timers
If you have never been to DiBella’s, the ordering process can feel a little fast. The staff expects you to know what you want. Here is a simple step-by-step guide.
- Decide on cold or hot before you reach the counter.
- Pick your bread type. The seeded roll is the signature choice.
- Choose your size. Regular is the standard for most people.
- Tell them the sub name or the meats you want.
- Select your cheese. Provolone is the default for most cold subs.
- Say “yes” when they ask if you want it toasted (for hot subs only).
- Choose your veggies. You can say “everything” to get lettuce, tomato, onion, and banana peppers.
- Pick your dressing. The oil and vinegar is the classic DiBella’s style.
- Pay at the register and grab your chips or cookie.
Do not be afraid to ask for a sample of the meat or cheese. They are usually happy to give you a small slice to try. This is especially helpful if you are torn between two options.
Nutritional Considerations
DiBella’s subs are not exactly health food. A Regular sub with cheese and oil can easily exceed 800 calories. If you are watching your intake, here are a few lighter choices.
- Order the Vegetarian sub on wheat bread with no oil
- Choose the Turkey Breast without cheese
- Get your sub as a bowl instead of on bread
- Ask for light mayo or dressing on the side
- Skip the chips and cookie
The bowl option is a hidden gem. You get all the meat, cheese, and veggies chopped up in a container without the bread. It costs the same as the sub, but it cuts out about 200 calories and a lot of carbs.
Location Variations And Pricing
One thing you should know is that prices are not identical at every DiBella’s location. Franchise owners set their own prices within a range allowed by the corporate office. Stores in high-rent areas like downtown Rochester or Pittsburgh will charge slightly more than suburban locations.
For example, a Regular Turkey Sub might cost $12.49 at a suburban store but $13.29 at a downtown location. The difference is usually between $0.50 and $1.50 per sub. If you are on a tight budget, it is worth driving to a location outside the city center.
You can also check the DiBella’s website for a digital menu. However, the online menu often shows the base price without tax or any location-specific adjustments. Call ahead if you need an exact price for a large catering order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does DiBella’s have a secret menu?
No official secret menu exists, but regulars know they can ask for the “DiBella’s Special” which adds extra oil and oregano to any cold sub. Some locations will also make a grilled version of a cold sub if you ask nicely.
Can I order DiBella’s subs online?
Yes, most locations accept online orders through their website or third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats. Online prices are usually the same as in-store, but delivery fees and tips will increase your total.
Are there any gluten-free bread options?
DiBella’s does not offer gluten-free bread at most locations. Your best bet is to order a bowl or a salad instead. You can still get all the meats and toppings without the roll.
What is the most popular sub at DiBella’s?
The DiBella sub, which combines ham, salami, and provolone, is the best seller. It is named after the founding family and has been on the menu since the beginning. The roast beef and turkey are also very popular.
Do DiBella’s prices include tax?
No, the menu prices do not include sales tax. You will pay the listed price plus your local tax rate. Some cities also have a prepared food tax, so the final bill might be a bit higher than you expect.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The DiBella’s Subs Menu with Prices is straightforward once you understand the size options and the quality of the ingredients. You are paying for Boar’s Head meats, fresh-baked bread, and a tradition that goes back over a century. The prices are fair for what you get.
If you want the best value, order a Regular size with the seeded roll, load up on free veggies, and skip the drink. That will put you right around $12.00 for a filling, high-quality meal. If you are feeding a crowd, the party tray is the way to go.
Next time you are near a DiBella’s, walk in with confidence. You now know what to expect, what to order, and how much it will cost. The bread will be fresh, the meat will be sliced to order, and you will understand why Rochester has been loyal to this shop for so many years.