Dicarlo’s Pizza built its reputation on the famous square slice, and their menu prices reflect a commitment to affordable, classic flavor. If you are looking for the full Dicarlo’s Pizza Menu with Prices, you have landed in the right spot. We have broken down every item, from the iconic old-world style pizza to the sides and drinks, so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in or order online.
Let us be clear about one thing right away. This is not your typical round, greasy slice. Dicarlo’s is famous for a cold, square-cut slice that is finished in the oven after you order it. That process gives the cheese a slight melt while keeping the dough dense and chewy. Prices vary slightly by location, but the list below reflects the standard rates across their Ohio, West Virginia, and Kentucky stores.
Dicarlo’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Below you will find the complete pricing structure for the main menu items. We have included the small, medium, and large options where applicable. Keep in mind that specialty pizzas and extra toppings will add to the base cost. The prices shown are accurate as of this writing, but local franchise owners sometimes adjust for food costs.
Pizza Sizes And Base Prices
Dicarlo’s sells their pizza by the square, but you order it as a whole sheet or by the box. The most common sizes are the small (four squares), medium (eight squares), and large (twelve squares). Here is the base price for a plain cheese pizza, which they call the “Original.”
- Small (4 squares) – $7.99
- Medium (8 squares) – $12.99
- Large (12 squares) – $16.99
- Party Tray (20 squares) – $24.99
That base cheese pizza comes with their signature sweet sauce and a thick layer of provolone cheese. You will notice the sauce is cold when it hits the box. That is intentional. The cold sauce is a hallmark of the “Steubenville-style” pizza that Dicarlo’s pioneered in the 1940s.
Specialty Pizzas
If you want something beyond plain cheese, Dicarlo’s offers a few house specialties. These come with pre-selected toppings and are priced slightly higher than a custom build. The most popular is the “DiCarlo’s Special,” which loads up pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and onions.
- DiCarlo’s Special (Medium) – $16.99
- DiCarlo’s Special (Large) – $20.99
- Supreme (Medium) – $17.99
- Supreme (Large) – $21.99
- White Pizza (Medium) – $14.99
- White Pizza (Large) – $18.99
Do not sleep on the white pizza. It swaps the red sauce for a garlic-ricotta base and adds extra mozzarella. It is a solid change of pace if you eat at Dicarlo’s often.
Individual Toppings Pricing
Building your own pizza is easy. Every topping is priced the same, whether you choose pepperoni, sausage, bacon, or vegetables. You can add as many as you like, but each one bumps the total up a bit. Here is the standard per-topping cost.
- Small – $0.75 per topping
- Medium – $1.25 per topping
- Large – $1.75 per topping
- Party Tray – $2.50 per topping
Available toppings include pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, ham, ground beef, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives, and extra cheese. Some locations also offer pineapple and jalapeños, but you may need to ask at the counter.
Baked Subs And Sandwiches
Dicarlo’s is not just a pizza joint. They serve a full line of hot subs and cold sandwiches. These are made on fresh-baked hoagie buns and come with chips or a small salad. The prices are budget-friendly, making them a good lunch option.
- Meatball Sub – $6.99
- Sausage Sub – $6.99
- Chicken Parm Sub – $7.49
- Eggplant Parm Sub – $7.49
- Italian Cold Cut – $6.49
- Turkey and Cheese – $6.49
- Ham and Cheese – $5.99
All subs are served hot unless you specifically order a cold cut. You can add extra cheese or toppings for a small upcharge of about fifty cents per item.
Wings And Sides
If you are feeding a group, you will want to add some wings or sides to your order. Dicarlo’s offers bone-in and boneless wings in a range of sauces. The sides are simple but filling, and they pair well with the square slices.
- Bone-in Wings (6 pc) – $7.99
- Bone-in Wings (12 pc) – $13.99
- Boneless Wings (6 pc) – $6.99
- Boneless Wings (12 pc) – $11.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $4.99
- Breadsticks (8 pc) – $5.49
- Side Salad – $3.99
- Antipasto Salad – $7.49
Wing sauces include mild, medium, hot, BBQ, garlic parmesan, and honey sriracha. If you like heat, go with the hot. It has a good kick without being overpowering.
Desserts And Drinks
Finish your meal with something sweet. Dicarlo’s keeps the dessert menu short, but the options are solid. They also have a full drink cooler with sodas, bottled water, and iced tea.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (large) – $3.49
- Brownie – $2.99
- Cannoli (2 pc) – $4.49
- Soft Drink (20 oz bottle) – $2.29
- Soft Drink (2-liter) – $3.49
- Bottled Water – $1.79
The cannoli is a house favorite. The shell is crisp, and the filling is sweet and creamy. It is a nice way to end a meal, especially if you are dining in.
How To Order Dicarlo’s Pizza
Ordering from Dicarlo’s is straightforward, but there are a few tips that will make the process smoother. Whether you call ahead or use their online portal, knowing the lingo helps. Here is a step-by-step guide to getting your order right.
- Decide on your size. Remember that a medium feeds two to three people, while a large feeds four to five.
- Choose your crust style. Dicarlo’s offers a regular dough and a thin crust. The thin crust is crispier and holds up better if you plan to reheat leftovers.
- Pick your toppings. You can go with a specialty pizza or build your own from the list above.
- Select your pickup time. Most locations have your order ready in fifteen to twenty minutes during peak hours.
- Pay at the counter or online. They accept cash, credit cards, and most mobile payment apps.
One important note: Dicarlo’s does not offer delivery at most locations. You will need to pick up your order or dine in. A few franchise spots have partnered with third-party delivery apps, but that is not guaranteed. Call your local store to confirm.
Dicarlo’s Pizza Prices Vs Competitors
When you compare Dicarlo’s to other regional pizza chains, the value is obvious. A large cheese pizza at a national chain often runs between $15 and $18. Dicarlo’s comes in at a similar price, but you get a denser, more filling product. The square slices are heavier than typical round slices, so you feel full faster.
Here is a quick comparison of average prices for a large cheese pizza at nearby competitors.
- Dicarlo’s – $16.99
- Donatos – $17.99
- Papa John’s – $18.49
- Domino’s – $15.99 (but often has coupons)
- Local independent shop – $14.00 to $20.00
Dicarlo’s sits right in the middle of the pack. You are not paying a premium, but you are also not getting the cheapest option. The tradeoff is the unique flavor profile. If you grew up in the Ohio Valley, no other pizza tastes quite like this one.
Tips For Saving Money On Dicarlo’s
Everyone likes a deal. Dicarlo’s runs specials throughout the week, and knowing when to go can save you a few bucks. Here are some practical ways to cut the cost of your order.
- Check the daily lunch special. Many locations offer a two-slice and drink combo for around $6.99 between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m.
- Look for coupon sheets in local mailers. Dicarlo’s frequently distributes discount codes for large pizzas.
- Join the email list. Some stores send out a welcome code for 10% off your first online order.
- Order a party tray if you are feeding a crowd. The per-square cost drops significantly compared to buying multiple smalls.
- Skip the extra toppings if you are on a budget. The cheese pizza is already flavorful on its own.
These tips are not guaranteed at every franchise, but they are common across the chain. It never hurts to ask the cashier if there are any active promotions.
What Makes Dicarlo’s Pizza Different
You might wonder why Dicarlo’s has such a loyal following. The answer lies in the preparation method. The pizza is assembled with cold sauce and cold cheese on a par-baked crust. When you order, they put the assembled pizza into a hot oven just long enough to warm the toppings and crisp the bottom.
This process means the sauce never cooks down into the cheese. You get a bright, sweet tomato flavor that stands out against the rich provolone. The crust is not airy like a Neapolitan pie. It is more like a thick, chewy flatbread with a slight crunch on the bottom.
Another hallmark is the square cut. Every pizza is sliced into rectangles rather than triangles. This gives you more edge pieces, which many fans consider the best part. The corners are especially crispy and carry a bit of caramelized cheese.
Frequently Asked Questions About Dicarlo’s Menu
Here are answers to the questions customers ask most often when they are looking at the Dicarlo’s menu and pricing.
Does Dicarlo’s offer gluten-free crust?
Yes, but not at every location. The gluten-free crust is a pre-made dough that is smaller than the regular size. It costs an extra $2.00 and is only available in a personal size. Call ahead to confirm your local store carries it.
Can you order Dicarlo’s pizza by the slice?
Yes, at most locations. You can buy a single square slice for about $2.50. This is a great option if you just want a quick snack. The slice is reheated in the oven before serving.
What are Dicarlo’s hours of operation?
Most stores open at 10:30 a.m. and close at 9:00 p.m. on weekdays. Friday and Saturday hours often extend to 10:00 p.m. Sunday hours are shorter, usually from 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Check your local store for exact times.
Does Dicarlo’s have a senior discount?
Some franchise locations offer a 10% discount for customers over 60. This is not a chain-wide policy, so you need to ask at the register. It is worth trying if you qualify.
Is the Dicarlo’s menu the same at all locations?
For the most part, yes. The core menu is identical across the chain. However, individual franchise owners can add local specialties or seasonal items. Prices also vary slightly by state due to food costs and labor rates.
Final Thoughts On Dicarlo’s Pricing
Dicarlo’s Pizza keeps things simple. The menu is not overly complicated, and the prices are fair for the quality and portion size. You are paying for a unique regional style that has survived for over seventy years. That consistency is worth something.
Next time you are in the mood for pizza, skip the generic chains and give Dicarlo’s a shot. Order a medium cheese pizza and a couple of cannolis. Your taste buds will thank you, and your wallet will not hate you either.
Remember to check the specific prices at your local Dicarlo’s before placing a large order. While the menu we listed is accurate for most stores, minor differences can pop up. A quick phone call will clear up any confusion and ensure you get exactly what you want at the right price.