Catfish Willy’s proves that Southern cooking doesn’t require a premium price tag when you know what to order. If you’re hunting for Catfish Willy’s Menu with Prices before you head out the door, you’re in the right place. This guide breaks down the full menu, what things cost, and which plates give you the most bang for your buck.
We have looked at the current offerings, talked to regulars, and checked the numbers. You will find clear prices, portion notes, and honest opinions on what is worth your cash. No fluff, just the facts you need for a solid meal.
Catfish Willy’s Menu With Prices
Let’s get right into the main event. The menu is built around classic Southern fare, with catfish as the star. But there is also chicken, shrimp, and burgers for those who want something different. Here is the breakdown of the main categories and their current price points.
Appetizers And Shareables
Starting with starters is a good move if you are hungry. These are great for the table, but watch out—they can fill you up before the main course arrives.
- Fried Pickles: $6.99. A solid portion of dill chips with a spicy ranch dip.
- Hush Puppies (6 pc): $3.49. Sweet, crispy, and served hot with butter.
- Onion Rings: $5.99. Beer-battered and thick cut. Good crunch.
- Fried Mushrooms: $6.49. Served with a side of marinara for dipping.
- Catfish Bites (Half lb): $8.99. Perfect for a quick snack or to share.
- Combo Basket: $10.99. A mix of pickles, rings, and mushrooms. Feeds two easily.
Most appetizers are sized for two or three people. If you are dining alone, the hush puppies are a safe bet without ruining your appetite.
Catfish Dinners (The Main Attraction)
This is why you came. The catfish is farm-raised, never frozen, and fried to order. You have options on how you want it fixed.
- Whole Catfish (Bone-in): $13.99. This is the traditional way. It is crispy on the outside and flaky inside.
- Catfish Fillets (2 pc): $12.49. Boneless and easy to eat. Great for kids or those who don’t like bones.
- Catfish Fillets (3 pc): $15.99. The better value if you are really hungry.
- Catfish & Shrimp Combo: $16.99. Two fillets and six fried shrimp. Best of both worlds.
- Grilled Catfish: $12.99. A lighter option. It comes with lemon butter and is less greasy.
Every dinner plate includes two sides and a basket of hush puppies. That is a lot of food for the price. The 3-piece fillet dinner is the best deal per ounce of fish.
Chicken And Other Fried Favorites
Not everyone wants fish. Catfish Willy’s covers you with chicken and other Southern staples.
- Chicken Tenders (3 pc): $9.99. Hand-breaded and juicy, not the frozen kind.
- Chicken Tenders (5 pc): $12.99. Served with your choice of two sides.
- Fried Shrimp Dinner: $13.99. You get about 12 medium shrimp, fried golden.
- Shrimp & Chicken Combo: $14.99. A mix of tenders and shrimp for the undecided.
- Fish & Chips: $11.49. Beer-battered white fish with steak fries.
The chicken tenders are a sleeper hit. They are thick and seasoned well. If you are bringing kids, the 3-piece meal is enough for them.
Burgers And Sandwiches
Lunch time brings out the sandwich board. These are smaller than the dinners but still filling.
- Catfish Po’ Boy: $10.49. Fried fillet on a toasted hoagie with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade.
- Burger (Half lb): $8.99. Hand-pressed and cooked to order. Comes with fries.
- Chicken Sandwich: $8.49. Fried or grilled, with pickles and onion.
- Shrimp Po’ Boy: $10.99. Loaded with fried shrimp and a spicy sauce.
- BLT: $7.99. Simple but done right with thick-cut bacon.
Sandwiches come with one side. The Po’ Boys are messy but worth it. Ask for extra napkins.
Sides And Extras
You can order sides a la carte if you want to mix and match. Here are the prices for individual sides.
- Coleslaw: $1.99
- French Fries: $2.49
- Steak Fries: $2.99
- Baked Potato: $2.49
- Mashed Potatoes & Gravy: $2.49
- Green Beans: $2.29
- Mac and Cheese: $2.99
- Corn on the Cob: $2.29
- Collard Greens: $2.49
- Hush Puppies (4 pc): $2.49
The mac and cheese is creamy and baked, not the watery kind. The green beans are cooked with bacon, which adds a nice smoky flavor.
Desserts And Drinks
Save room if you can. The desserts are homemade and rotate daily.
- Peach Cobbler: $4.99. Served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
- Banana Pudding: $3.99. Old-school style with vanilla wafers.
- Chocolate Cake: $4.49. Dense and fudgy.
- Sweet Tea (Glass): $2.29
- Sweet Tea (Pitcher): $6.99. Enough for two or three people.
- Soft Drinks: $2.49. Free refills on all fountain drinks.
The sweet tea is properly sweet, not just slightly sweetened. If you are not from the South, you might want to ask for half sweet and half unsweet.
Daily Specials And Deals
Catfish Willy’s runs daily specials that change the value equation. If you are on a budget, these are the days to go.
- Monday: All-you-can-eat catfish for $16.99. This is the best deal of the week.
- Tuesday: Two-for-one burger night. Buy one burger, get one free.
- Wednesday: Half-price appetizers after 4 PM.
- Thursday: Shrimp dinner special for $11.99 instead of $13.99.
- Friday: Fish sandwich special for $7.99 all day.
These specials are not advertised heavily, so you have to ask or check the board at the counter. The Monday all-you-can-eat is worth planning around.
Kids Menu And Senior Portions
Families are welcome here. The kids menu has smaller portions and lower prices.
- Kids Catfish Fingers (2 pc): $5.99. Includes one side and a drink.
- Kids Chicken Tenders (2 pc): $5.49. Includes one side and a drink.
- Kids Burger: $4.99. Small patty with fries.
- Kids Mac and Cheese: $3.99. Comes with a side of fruit.
Seniors get a 10% discount on any entree with a valid ID. Just mention it when you order. That discount applies to the regular menu prices, not the daily specials.
How To Order And Save Money
You can save a few bucks if you know how the system works. Here are some tips from regulars.
- Skip the appetizer: The hush puppies that come with dinner are enough to start.
- Order water: Sweet tea is good, but it adds $2.29 to your bill. Water is free.
- Share a 3-piece dinner: It is huge. Two people can split it and add a side for $2.49.
- Go on Monday: The all-you-can-eat catfish is the best value if you are very hungry.
- Check for coupons: They sometimes put a coupon in the local paper or on their Facebook page.
Following these steps can cut your bill by 20-30%. The food is good at full price, but it is great when you pay less.
What Is Worth The Money?
Not everything on the menu is a home run. Here is our honest take on what to order and what to skip.
Worth it:
- The 3-piece catfish fillet dinner. It is the best portion-to-price ratio.
- The fried pickles. They are crispy and not too salty.
- The Monday all-you-can-eat special. Bring your appetite.
- The peach cobbler. It tastes like it came from a home kitchen.
Skip it:
- The BLT. It is fine, but you can get a better one at a diner for less.
- The grilled catfish. It is dry compared to the fried version.
- The onion rings. They are good but too greasy for the price.
Stick to the fried items and you will leave happy. That is what this place does best.
Location And Hours
Catfish Willy’s has one main location, though they sometimes run a food truck at local events. The restaurant is at 4823 Old Highway 11, just outside of town. There is plenty of parking, including spots for trucks and trailers.
- Monday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 7:00 PM
They close early on Sundays, so plan accordingly. The kitchen stops taking orders 30 minutes before closing, so do not show up at 8:25 PM on a weeknight.
The dining room is casual with a mix of booths and tables. You order at the counter and they bring the food to you. It is not fancy, but it is clean and comfortable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people ask about the menu and prices.
Does Catfish Willy’s take credit cards?
Yes, they accept all major credit cards and debit cards. They also take cash. There is no extra fee for using a card.
Is there a gluten-free option on the menu?
Very limited. The grilled catfish is gluten-free, but it is cooked on shared equipment. If you have celiac disease, this is not the safest place to eat.
Can I order takeout or delivery?
Takeout is available by calling ahead. They do not partner with DoorDash or Uber Eats. You have to pick it up yourself.
Are the prices the same for dine-in and takeout?
Yes, the prices are identical. There is no upcharge for takeout orders.
Do they offer catering for events?
Yes, they do. You can order trays of catfish, chicken, and sides for parties. Call at least 48 hours in advance for catering orders.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
Catfish Willy’s delivers solid Southern food at fair prices. The portions are generous, and the quality is consistent. You will not find gourmet plating or trendy ingredients here. What you will find is honest cooking that tastes like it came from a family reunion.
Go for the fried catfish, skip the grilled stuff, and take advantage of the Monday special. Bring cash if you want to tip the counter staff, though card tips are accepted. Your total for a dinner with a drink and dessert will land around $18 to $22 per person. That is a fair deal for the amount of food you get.
Next time you are driving down Old Highway 11 and smell that frying oil, pull in. You now know exactly what to order and what it will cost. No surprises, just good eats.