College Pizza serves the late-night study crowd, but the price board up front also tempts the faculty who stop by for weekday slices. If you are looking for a full breakdown of the College Pizza Menu with Prices, you landed in the right spot. We checked the current board, talked to the staff, and even peeked at the online ordering system so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in.
The menu is not huge, but it covers all the bases. You get your classic cheese, pepperoni, and a few specialty pies. They also sell calzones, wings, and a simple salad selection. Below is the complete rundown, including the tax situation and which deals actually save you money.
College Pizza Menu With Prices
Before we get into the deep list, here is a fast snapshot of the most ordered items. These prices are from the current in-store menu board. Delivery apps might show a slight markup, so keep that in mind if you order from a third party.
- Cheese Slice – $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.75
- Specialty Slice – $4.50
- Small Cheese Pie (10″) – $10.99
- Medium Cheese Pie (14″) – $14.99
- Large Cheese Pie (16″) – $17.99
- Extra Toppings – $1.75 each
- Chicken Wings (6 pcs) – $8.99
- Chicken Wings (12 pcs) – $15.99
- Garden Salad – $7.49
- Chicken Caesar Salad – $8.99
- Calzone (Cheese) – $9.99
- Calzone (Meat) – $11.99
- Garlic Knots (6 pcs) – $5.49
- Canned Soda – $1.50
- Bottled Water – $1.75
That list gives you the basics. Now, let us break down each category in more detail. You will also find some notes about portion sizes and what the regulars usually order.
Pizza Slices And Whole Pies
The slice counter is the busiest part of the shop between 9 PM and midnight. They keep a steady rotation of cheese and pepperoni going, plus one or two specialty slices depending on the day. If you want a slice of something specific, call ahead to check availability.
Whole pies are made to order. You can expect about a 15 to 20 minute wait during peak hours. The crust is thin-ish, not cracker thin, but not deep dish either. It holds up well to heavy toppings.
Here is the full pricing for pies and slices:
- Cheese Slice – $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.75
- Specialty Slice (changes daily) – $4.50
- Small Cheese Pie (10″, serves 1-2) – $10.99
- Medium Cheese Pie (14″, serves 2-3) – $14.99
- Large Cheese Pie (16″, serves 3-4) – $17.99
- Small Specialty Pie – $13.99
- Medium Specialty Pie – $18.99
- Large Specialty Pie – $22.99
Specialty pies include the usual suspects. You got the BBQ Chicken, the Veggie Deluxe, and the Meat Lovers. They also do a Buffalo Chicken pie that is pretty popular with the dorm crowd. Each specialty pie comes with the toppings already included in the base price.
Extra toppings on a whole pie cost $1.75 each. That applies to standard items like mushrooms, onions, peppers, sausage, and extra cheese. Premium meats like bacon or chicken are $2.25 each. If you load up a large pizza with four or five extras, the price climbs fast. Sometimes it is cheaper to just get a specialty pie instead of customizing a cheese pizza.
Calzones And Stromboli
The calzone section is smaller, but the portions are generous. A calzone here is folded pizza dough stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of fillings. It comes with a small cup of marinara sauce on the side for dipping.
Calzone options and prices:
- Cheese Calzone – $9.99
- Pepperoni Calzone – $10.99
- Meat Calzone (pepperoni, sausage, ham) – $11.99
- Veggie Calzone – $10.99
- Chicken Alfredo Calzone – $11.49
Each calzone is big enough for one hungry person. If you have a smaller appetite, you could split one and add a side salad. The chicken alfredo one is creamy and heavy, so do not plan on studying right after eating it. You will want a nap.
Wings And Sides
Wings are not the main attraction here, but they are a solid side order. They come in mild, medium, hot, BBQ, or garlic parmesan. The sauce is tossed on after frying, so the skin stays crispy.
Wing pricing:
- 6 Pieces – $8.99
- 12 Pieces – $15.99
- 24 Pieces (party tray) – $29.99
You can get them with celery and a choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing. The ranch costs an extra $0.75 if you want a second cup. They are not the biggest wings you have ever seen, but they are not tiny either. The 12-piece order is usually enough for two people if you also get a pizza.
Other sides include garlic knots, breadsticks, and a small side salad.
- Garlic Knots (6 pcs) – $5.49
- Breadsticks (4 pcs) – $4.99
- Side Salad – $4.99
- French Fries – $3.99
The garlic knots come with a little container of marinara. They are brushed with garlic oil and sprinkled with parmesan. They are a good cheap filler if you are splitting a pie with friends and need extra food on the table.
Salads And Vegetarian Options
If you are trying to eat lighter, the salad selection is basic but fresh. The greens are pre-mixed, and the toppings are standard. You can add chicken to any salad for an extra $2.50.
Salad prices:
- Garden Salad – $7.49
- Chicken Caesar Salad – $8.99
- Greek Salad – $8.49
- Antipasto Salad – $9.99
The Greek salad comes with feta, olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, and red onion. The antipasto has ham, salami, provolone, and pepperoncini. Both are decent portions. You get a full meal out of them, not just a side dish.
For vegetarians, the veggie pizza and the cheese calzone are the safest bets. The veggie pie comes with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and black olives. You can also ask for no cheese if you are vegan, but they do not have dairy-free cheese available.
Drinks And Desserts
The drink selection is mostly canned and bottled. They have a soda fountain, but it is self-serve and only for dine-in customers. If you are taking out, you get a canned drink.
- Canned Soda (Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite) – $1.50
- Bottled Water – $1.75
- Iced Tea (bottled) – $2.25
- Energy Drink – $3.49
For dessert, they have a few options behind the counter. The selection changes, but you can usually find:
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (large) – $2.99
- Brownie – $2.49
- Cannoli (2 pcs) – $4.99
The cannoli are brought in from a local bakery, not made in-house. They are still pretty good. The cookie is huge, like the size of your face. It is a good shareable dessert if you are with a group.
Deals And Combo Specials
College Pizza runs a few daily specials that are not always listed on the online menu. You have to ask at the counter or check the whiteboard near the register.
Current deals we confirmed:
- Monday: Large cheese pie for $14.99 (normally $17.99)
- Tuesday: Buy one calzone, get a side salad free
- Wednesday: 12 wings + fries for $16.99
- Thursday: Large specialty pie for $19.99 (select toppings only)
- Friday-Sunday: No specials, regular pricing applies
There is also a student discount if you show a valid student ID. It is 10% off your entire order, but only for dine-in or pickup. It does not apply to delivery orders placed through apps. You also cannot stack the student discount with the daily specials. It is one or the other.
If you are ordering for a group, the large pizza + 12 wings combo is the best value. That runs about $33.98 before tax. It feeds three or four people comfortably. If you are just feeding yourself, the two-slice deal is the way to go. You get two cheese slices and a canned soda for $6.99. That is only available Monday through Thursday until 4 PM.
Ordering And Payment Options
You can order in person, over the phone, or through their website. The website has a simple interface. You pick your items, choose pickup or delivery, and pay online. Delivery is only available within a 3-mile radius. The delivery fee is $2.99, and the driver expects a tip on top of that.
Phone orders are still the fastest if you want to customize something. The staff is used to taking complicated orders. Just be ready to repeat your phone number twice. They always ask for it.
Payment methods accepted:
- Cash
- Credit/Debit cards (Visa, Mastercard, Amex)
- Apple Pay and Google Pay
- Campus meal plan (only for dine-in, not delivery)
The meal plan acceptance is a big deal for students. You can use your declining balance dollars to pay for food. That does not work on the delivery apps though. You have to order directly through the store for that.
Hours And Location Notes
College Pizza is open late, which is why it is so popular with students. The hours are:
- Monday – Thursday: 11 AM to 2 AM
- Friday – Saturday: 11 AM to 3 AM
- Sunday: 12 PM to 1 AM
The kitchen stops taking orders 30 minutes before closing. So if you roll in at 1:45 AM on a Saturday, you might be out of luck. The slice counter stays open until the very end, but they only have whatever is left in the warmer. Once the slices run out, they do not make more.
The shop is located right across from the main campus gate, near the bus stop. There is limited street parking, but most people walk or bike. If you drive, there is a small lot behind the building with about 10 spaces. It fills up fast during lunch rush.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people ask about the menu and pricing at College Pizza.
Does College Pizza offer a student discount?
Yes. Show a valid student ID at the counter and you get 10% off your order. This applies to dine-in and pickup orders only. It cannot be combined with daily specials or used on third-party delivery apps.
Are there gluten-free crust options?
They offer a gluten-free crust for an extra $3.00 on any whole pie. The crust is pre-made and frozen, not prepared in a separate area. If you have a severe gluten allergy, this is not a safe option due to cross-contamination.
What is the delivery radius and fee?
Delivery is available within a 3-mile radius of the store. The delivery fee is $2.99. There is no minimum order amount for delivery, but the driver does accept tips. Expect a 30 to 45 minute wait during peak hours.
Can I use my campus meal plan here?
Yes, for dine-in and pickup orders placed directly with the store. The meal plan does not work on third-party delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats. You need to call or order through their website to use your declining balance.
What are the most affordable items on the menu?
The cheapest filling option is the two-slice deal at $6.99, available Monday through Thursday until 4 PM. A single cheese slice is $3.25. Garlic knots are $5.49. If you want a full meal for under $8, go with the side salad and a slice of cheese pizza.
Final Thoughts On Pricing And Value
College Pizza is not the cheapest pizza in town, but it is far from the most expensive. The quality is consistent, and the location is unbeatable for students. The slice prices are fair for the portion size. A single slice is pretty large, easily enough for a light meal.
The best value on the menu is the Monday large cheese pie special at $14.99. That is a solid price for a 16-inch pizza. The student discount on top of regular prices also helps. If you are a student and you eat here often, the 10% adds up over the semester.
One thing to watch out for is the extra topping costs. They seem small at $1.75 each, but they add up quickly. A large cheese with four toppings costs $24.99. At that point, you might as well get a specialty pie for $22.99 and save two bucks.
Overall, College Pizza delivers exactly what you expect from a campus pizza joint. The menu is straightforward, the prices are reasonable, and the food hits the spot when you need a late-night meal. Keep this price guide handy so you know what to order before you walk in.