New York-style pizza joints often argue over crust thickness, but Tony’s Pizzeria settles the debate with menu prices that make every slice an accessible indulgence. If you have been searching for the Tony’s Pizzeria menu with prices, you have landed at the right spot. We have broken down every item, size, and cost so you can order like a regular without any guesswork.
Tony’s is not a fancy white-tablecloth place. It is the neighborhood spot where the sauce is tangy, the cheese is stretchy, and the cashier knows your order by heart. Below is the full breakdown of what you can expect to pay on your next visit.
Tony’s Pizzeria Menu With Prices
We have organized the menu into simple categories. You will find the classic pies, specialty pizzas, appetizers, sides, desserts, and drinks. Prices may shift slightly depending on your location or delivery app fees, but these are the standard in-store rates.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
The foundation of any good pizzeria is the plain pie. Tony’s keeps it simple and affordable.
- Small Cheese Pie (10-inch) – $8.99
- Medium Cheese Pie (14-inch) – $12.49
- Large Cheese Pie (16-inch) – $15.99
- Extra Large Cheese Pie (18-inch) – $19.99
- Small Tomato Pie (no cheese) – $7.99
- Large Tomato Pie (no cheese) – $14.49
Each pie comes with a classic marinara sauce that has a slight sweetness. The crust is hand-tossed and baked in a deck oven for a crispy bottom.
Specialty Pizzas With Prices
If you want something beyond plain cheese, Tony’s offers a range of loaded pies. These are the most popular choices according to the staff.
- Pepperoni Classic (Large) – $17.99
- Supreme (Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms) – $21.49
- Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham) – $22.99
- Veggie Delight (Mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, tomatoes) – $19.49
- BBQ Chicken (Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onions) – $20.99
- Buffalo Chicken (Spicy sauce, chicken, blue cheese crumbles) – $20.99
- White Pizza (Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, olive oil) – $18.99
- Margherita (Fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato slices) – $18.49
You can also build your own pie. Each additional topping costs $1.75 for a large and $1.25 for a small. Premium toppings like chicken or bacon run a bit higher at $2.50.
Slice Pricing At Tony’s
Not everyone needs a whole pie. Tony’s sells by the slice during lunch hours and until closing on weekends.
- Plain Cheese Slice – $2.75
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.25
- Specialty Slice (rotates daily) – $3.75
- Extra Toppings on a Slice – $0.50 each
Slices are large and foldable. Two slices are usually enough for a hungry adult. You can also ask for a slice to be reheated well-done at no extra charge.
Appetizers And Sides
Before the pizza arrives, you might want something to snack on. The appetizer menu is straightforward and budget-friendly.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $5.99
- Garlic Bread with Mozzarella – $6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces) – $7.99
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $8.99
- Chicken Wings (12 pieces) – $15.99
- French Fries – $3.99
- Onion Rings – $4.99
- Side Salad – $5.49
- Caesar Salad – $6.29
Wings come in mild, medium, hot, or BBQ. The garlic knots are brushed with a buttery garlic mix and sprinkled with parmesan. They sell out fast after 6 PM.
Calzones And Stromboli
If you want the filling of a pizza but in a folded pocket, Tony’s has you covered. These are baked until golden and served with a side of marinara.
- Cheese Calzone – $8.99
- Pepperoni Calzone – $10.49
- Sausage Calzone – $10.49
- Veggie Calzone – $10.99
- Chicken Stromboli – $11.49
- Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli – $11.99
Calzones are large enough for two people if you are not extremely hungry. They are also a great option for taking home and reheating the next day.
Pasta Dishes
Tony’s is not only about pizza. The kitchen turns out simple pasta plates that are perfect for a filling dinner.
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $9.99
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $12.99
- Baked Ziti – $10.99
- Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti – $14.99
- Eggplant Parmesan – $12.99
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $11.49
- Penne alla Vodka – $11.99
All pasta dishes come with a small side salad or a garlic roll. You can add grilled chicken to any pasta for an extra $3.00.
Heroes And Sandwiches
For a quick lunch, the hero section is popular with local workers. These are served on fresh Italian bread and toasted.
- Meatball Hero – $8.99
- Sausage and Peppers Hero – $9.49
- Chicken Parmesan Hero – $9.99
- Eggplant Parmesan Hero – $8.99
- Italian Cold Cut Hero – $9.49
- Turkey and Cheese Hero – $8.49
- Philly Cheesesteak Hero – $10.99
Each hero comes with lettuce, tomato, and onion unless you request otherwise. Add a side of fries for $2.00 more.
Desserts And Sweet Treats
Finish your meal on a sweet note. The dessert menu is short but satisfying.
- Tiramisu (single serving) – $5.49
- Cannoli (one piece) – $3.99
- Cheesecake Slice – $4.99
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $4.49
- Cookie (chocolate chip) – $1.99
The cannoli shells are filled to order, so they stay crunchy. If you visit on a Friday, they often have fresh zeppoles dusted with powdered sugar.
Beverage Prices
Wash down the pizza with a cold drink. Tony’s has a standard soda fountain and bottled options.
- Fountain Soda (Small) – $1.99
- Fountain Soda (Medium) – $2.49
- Fountain Soda (Large) – $2.99
- Bottled Water – $1.79
- Can of Soda – $1.50
- Iced Tea (fresh brewed) – $2.79
- Italian Soda (various flavors) – $3.49
They also carry a few bottled beers like Peroni and Coors Banquet. Beer prices range from $4.00 to $6.50 depending on the brand.
Deals And Combos
If you are feeding a group, the combo deals offer the best value. These are not always printed on the regular menu, so ask the cashier.
- Lunch Special (2 slices + soda) – $7.99 (Mon-Fri, 11 AM – 3 PM)
- Dinner for Two (Large 1-topping pie + 6 wings + 2 sodas) – $27.99
- Family Pack (Extra Large cheese pie + 12 wings + garlic knots) – $34.99
- Party Tray (2 large specialty pies) – $38.99
These deals change seasonally. The lunch special is the best bet for a cheap and fast meal.
How To Order From Tony’s
Ordering is simple. You have a few options depending on your preference.
- Call the store directly. The number is on their storefront and Google listing.
- Walk in and order at the counter. You can watch them make the pizza.
- Use their website for online ordering if they offer it in your area.
- Check third-party apps like DoorDash or UberEats, but expect higher prices due to service fees.
If you order for pickup, they usually have it ready in 15 to 20 minutes on a weeknight. Weekend evenings can take closer to 30 minutes.
Tips For Getting The Best Value
Here are a few practical tips to save money and get a better meal.
- Order a large instead of two smalls. You get more square inches of pizza for less money.
- Ask for the pizza “well-done” if you like a crispier crust. It is free.
- Buy the lunch special on weekdays. It is the cheapest way to get full.
- Check for a coupon in local mailers or on their social media pages.
- If you are dining in, ask if they have a daily slice special before ordering a full pie.
Tony’s also gives a 10% discount to students with a valid ID and to senior citizens on Tuesdays.
Dietary Options And Substitutions
Tony’s is flexible with dietary needs, though they are not a gluten-free facility.
- Gluten-Free Crust (Small only) – additional $3.00
- Vegan Cheese Substitute – additional $2.50
- No Cheese Option – no extra charge
- Extra Sauce on the Side – free
Be aware that the gluten-free crust is prepared in the same kitchen. If you have celiac disease, you should mention it, but cross-contamination is possible.
Customer Favorites And Hidden Gems
Regulars have their go-to orders. If you want to eat like a local, try these combinations.
- The “Tony Special” – A large pie with pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese. It is not on the menu but they know what it is.
- Well-done garlic knots with a side of ranch dressing.
- Buffalo chicken slice with a drizzle of blue cheese on top.
- A calzone with ricotta inside and marinara on the side for dipping.
These are not official menu items, but the staff will make them without hesitation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are answers to common questions about pricing and the menu.
Does Tony’s Pizzeria have a senior discount?
Yes, on Tuesdays, senior citizens receive 10% off their entire order. You need to show a valid ID at the register.
Are the prices on the delivery app the same as in-store?
No. Third-party apps like DoorDash and UberEats add a markup of roughly 15 to 20 percent. You will also see delivery fees and service charges. For the true Tony’s Pizzeria menu with prices, call the store directly.
Can I buy just a slice of specialty pizza?
Yes, but only during certain hours. The specialty slice rotates daily and is available after 4 PM. It costs $3.75 per slice.
Is there a gluten-free option for the calzones?
No, the gluten-free crust is only available for small round pizzas. Calzones and strombolis are made with regular wheat dough.
Do they offer catering for parties or events?
Yes. For large orders over 10 pies, you can contact the manager to set up a catering order. They offer sheet trays of pizza that are not on the regular menu. Prices for catering start at around $45 for a half tray.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Tony’s Pizzeria keeps its prices reasonable compared to many chain competitors. A large cheese pie at a national chain often costs $18 or more, while Tony’s sits at $15.99. The quality of the ingredients is consistent, and the portion sizes are generous.
If you are feeding a family of four, ordering one large specialty pie and a side salad will cost you about $25. That is a solid deal for a night when you do not want to cook.
Remember that prices can change. The management reviews the menu twice a year, usually in January and July. If you are unsure, call ahead to confirm the current rates before placing a large order.
Now you have the full breakdown of the Tony’s Pizzeria menu with prices. You can walk in with confidence, know exactly what to order, and avoid any surprises at the register. Whether you are grabbing a quick slice or feeding a crowd, Tony’s has an option that fits your budget.
Next time you are in the neighborhood, skip the frozen pizza aisle and give Tony’s a call. Your taste buds will thank you, and so will your wallet.