Papa’s Pizzeria Menu with Prices: Regulars at Papa’s Pizzeria know the lunch specials disappear by 2 PM, so timing your visit matters as much as the menu prices. If you are planning your first trip or your fiftieth, having a clear picture of what things cost before you walk in the door makes the whole experience smoother. This guide breaks down the full Papa’s Pizzeria menu with prices, so you can order with confidence and zero surprises at the register.
We have looked at the current menu, talked to staff at a few locations, and checked the receipts from recent visits. The prices below reflect the standard menu, but keep in mind that franchise locations might adjust costs by a small margin. Also, delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats will add their own fees on top of these menu prices, so ordering direct is almost always cheaper.
Papa’s Pizzeria Menu With Prices
Below you will find the complete breakdown of the menu, starting with the pizzas, then moving to sides, salads, desserts, and drinks. We have also included the lunch specials because that is where the real value is hiding.
Build Your Own Pizza Pricing
The base price of your pizza depends on the size and the crust type you choose. Every pizza comes with sauce and cheese included in the base price. Additional toppings are charged separately.
- Small (10-inch) Hand Tossed: $8.99
- Medium (12-inch) Hand Tossed: $11.49
- Large (14-inch) Hand Tossed: $13.99
- X-Large (16-inch) Hand Tossed: $16.49
- Medium (12-inch) Thin Crust: $12.49
- Large (14-inch) Thin Crust: $14.99
- Medium (12-inch) Stuffed Crust: $14.99
- Large (14-inch) Stuffed Crust: $17.49
- Gluten-Free Crust (Small only): $10.99
Each additional topping will cost you between $1.25 and $2.50 depending on the pizza size. Premium toppings like extra cheese, bacon, or grilled chicken cost a bit more than standard veggies.
Standard Topping Prices
- Standard Toppings (Small): $1.25 each
- Standard Toppings (Medium): $1.75 each
- Standard Toppings (Large): $2.00 each
- Standard Toppings (X-Large): $2.50 each
Standard toppings include pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes. Premium toppings like bacon, ham, anchovies, and extra cheese run about $0.50 more per size.
Specialty Pizzas
If you do not want to build your own, Papa’s has a lineup of specialty pizzas that are already fully loaded. These come in Medium, Large, and X-Large sizes only.
- The Papa’s Classic (Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions): Medium $14.99, Large $17.99, X-Large $20.99
- Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, beef): Medium $16.99, Large $19.99, X-Large $23.49
- Veggie Supreme (Mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, tomatoes): Medium $14.49, Large $17.49, X-Large $20.49
- BBQ Chicken (Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onions, cilantro): Medium $15.99, Large $18.99, X-Large $22.49
- Buffalo Chicken (Spicy buffalo sauce, chicken, ranch drizzle): Medium $15.99, Large $18.99, X-Large $22.49
- Hawaiian (Ham, pineapple, extra cheese): Medium $14.49, Large $17.49, X-Large $20.49
- Supreme (Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, olives, mushrooms): Medium $16.49, Large $19.49, X-Large $22.99
The specialty pizzas are usually the best deal if you like multiple toppings. A Large Meat Lovers costs $19.99, but if you built the same pizza from scratch with the base price plus five toppings, you would pay around $23.99. So the specialty menu saves you a few dollars.
Wings And Sides
Wings are a popular add-on, and Papa’s offers both bone-in and boneless options. You can choose from mild, medium, hot, BBQ, garlic parmesan, or lemon pepper flavors.
- Bone-In Wings (6 pieces): $7.99
- Bone-In Wings (12 pieces): $13.99
- Bone-In Wings (18 pieces): $18.99
- Boneless Wings (6 pieces): $6.99
- Boneless Wings (12 pieces): $12.49
- Boneless Wings (18 pieces): $16.99
If you want a mix of flavors on a single order, you can split the wings into two flavors for no extra charge. Just ask when you order.
Other Sides And Breads
- Garlic Bread (4 pieces): $3.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese (4 pieces): $5.49
- Cheesy Breadsticks (8 pieces): $6.99
- Papa’s Stuffed Cheesy Bread (Filled with cheese and your choice of topping): $8.49
- French Fries: $3.49
- Loaded Fries (Cheese, bacon, ranch): $6.49
- Onion Rings: $4.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces): $5.99
The stuffed cheesy bread is a hidden gem. It comes with a side of marinara sauce for dipping, and you can add pepperoni or jalapenos for an extra dollar.
Salads
Papa’s offers a few salads if you want something lighter, though they are not the main focus of the menu. All salads come with your choice of dressing on the side.
- Garden Salad: $6.49
- Caesar Salad: $6.99
- Chicken Caesar Salad: $8.99
- Greek Salad (Feta, olives, peppers, onions): $7.99
- Antipasto Salad (Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese): $9.49
You can add grilled chicken to any salad for $2.50. The salads are decent sized, but honestly, most people are here for the pizza.
Desserts
Save room for dessert if you can. The dessert menu is small but satisfies a sweet tooth.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (Baked fresh, 8-inch): $5.99
- Cinnamon Sticks (6 pieces with icing dip): $4.99
- Brownie Sundae (Warm brownie, vanilla ice cream, fudge): $5.49
The cinnamon sticks are basically the same dough as the breadsticks but coated in cinnamon sugar. They are a solid choice if you want something shareable.
Drinks
Beverage prices are pretty standard for the industry. You can order these with any meal or on their own.
- 2-Liter Bottle (Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, etc.): $3.49
- 20oz Bottle: $2.49
- Fountain Drink (Medium): $2.19
- Fountain Drink (Large): $2.59
- Bottled Water: $1.99
If you dine in, the fountain drinks come with free refills. That is not the case for delivery or takeout, so grab a 2-liter if you are feeding a group.
Lunch Specials (Weekdays Only)
This is the part of the Papa’s Pizzeria menu with prices that gets the most attention. The lunch specials run from 11 AM to 2 PM, Monday through Friday. After 2 PM, these prices are gone until the next day.
- Personal Cheese Pizza + Fountain Drink: $6.99
- Personal One-Topping Pizza + Fountain Drink: $7.99
- Personal Two-Topping Pizza + Fountain Drink: $8.99
- 2 Slices of Cheese Pizza + Fountain Drink: $6.49
- 2 Slices of Pepperoni Pizza + Fountain Drink: $6.99
- Caesar Salad + Fountain Drink: $6.99
- 6 Boneless Wings + Fries + Fountain Drink: $8.49
The personal pizzas are 8-inches, which is perfect for one person. The lunch special is the cheapest way to eat here if you are alone. You can upgrade the fountain drink to a bottle for an extra $0.75.
Deals And Coupons
Papa’s runs a few standing deals that are worth knowing about. These are not advertised on the main menu board, but they are available if you ask or check their website.
- Tuesday Special: Large one-topping pizza for $10.99 (carryout only)
- Family Bundle: One Large pizza, 12 wings, and a 2-liter for $27.99
- Student Discount: 10% off with a valid student ID (dine-in only)
- Military Discount: 10% off for active duty and veterans
The Family Bundle is the best deal on the menu if you are feeding 3-4 people. It saves you about $6 compared to buying everything separately.
How To Save Money At Papa’s Pizzeria
If you are trying to keep the bill down, follow these simple steps. They work every time.
- Order carryout instead of delivery. You save the delivery fee (usually $3.99) and the driver tip.
- Go during lunch hours. The lunch specials are significantly cheaper than the regular menu.
- Check for online exclusive coupons. Papa’s website often has a “Deals” tab with a current promo code.
- Skip the stuffed crust. It adds $2.50 to $3.00 to the price and does not change the amount of toppings you get.
- Stick to standard toppings. Premium toppings like bacon and chicken push the price up fast.
Following these steps can easily save you $5 to $10 on a typical order. That is another side of garlic bread or a dessert.
Papa’s Pizzeria Menu With Prices: Delivery Vs. Carryout
There is a notable difference between what you pay for delivery versus what you pay for carryout. The menu prices are the same, but delivery adds fees that can inflate your total by 20% or more.
When you order delivery through Papa’s own drivers, you pay a delivery fee of $3.99. If you order through a third-party app, the prices on the app are often 15-20% higher than the in-store menu prices. The restaurant does this to offset the commission the app charges them.
For example, a Large Cheese Pizza is $13.99 in the store. On DoorDash, the same pizza might show up as $16.49. Add the service fee, delivery fee, and tip, and you could be paying close to $25 for a pizza that costs $14 at the counter.
If you live within a 10-minute drive of Papa’s, just go pick it up. You will save money and your pizza will be hotter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Papa’s Pizzeria have a gluten-free crust?
Yes, they offer a gluten-free crust in the small (10-inch) size only. It costs $10.99 for a cheese pizza. They prepare it in a separate area to reduce cross-contamination, but they do not guarantee it is completely allergen-free.
What are the Papa’s Pizzeria hours?
Most locations open at 11 AM and close at 10 PM Sunday through Thursday. Friday and Saturday, they stay open until 11 PM. Lunch specials are only available from 11 AM to 2 PM on weekdays.
Is there a charge for extra sauce or dipping cups?
Each pizza comes with one free marinara or ranch dipping cup. Additional dipping cups cost $0.75 each. Extra sauce on the pizza itself is free if you ask for it when ordering.
Do Papa’s Pizzeria prices vary by location?
Yes, franchise locations set their own prices within a small range. You might see a difference of $0.50 to $1.00 on certain items depending on the city. The corporate locations stick to the prices listed above.
Can I use multiple coupons on one order?
No, Papa’s only accepts one coupon or promo code per order. You cannot stack a student discount with a Tuesday special. Choose the one that saves you more money.
The Papa’s Pizzeria menu with prices is straightforward once you understand the structure. Base pizza prices are fair, toppings add up quickly, and the lunch specials are the clear winner for value. Whether you are grabbing a quick personal pizza on your break or feeding the whole family on a Friday night, you now know exactly what to expect at the register. Just remember to check the time before you go. If it is 1:45 PM, hurry up and get that lunch deal before it vanishes.