Pappa Pey Pey Pizza brings a playful name to the table, yet the menu pricing for its specialty pies and sides follows a more serious structure. If you are looking for the full Pappa Pey Pey Pizza menu with prices, you have come to the right place. We have broken down every category, from classic cheese to loaded meat options, so you know exactly what to expect before you order.
This guide covers the current cost of every item, portion sizes, and which deals give you the most value. We also explain how the pricing works for custom toppings and gluten-free crusts. Let us walk you through the whole menu, item by item, so you can plan your next meal without any guesswork.
Pappa Pey Pey Pizza Menu With Prices
The menu is split into clear sections: Classic Pizzas, Specialty Pies, Sides, Desserts, and Drinks. Prices vary depending on the size you choose. Most locations offer Small (10″), Medium (12″), Large (14″), and Extra Large (16″). The table below shows the standard pricing for the most popular items.
Classic Cheese And Pepperoni Pizzas
These are the building blocks of the menu. They are simple, consistent, and affordable. If you are feeding a crowd or just want a reliable base for your own toppings, start here.
- Cheese Pizza – Small $9.99, Medium $12.49, Large $14.99, XL $17.49
- Pepperoni Pizza – Small $11.49, Medium $13.99, Large $16.49, XL $18.99
- Extra Cheese – Add $2.00 to any size
- Mushroom Pizza – Small $11.99, Medium $14.49, Large $16.99, XL $19.49
You can also build your own pizza. The base price is the same as a cheese pizza. Then you add toppings at a fixed rate. We will cover that in detail later in this article.
Specialty Signature Pies
These are the pizzas that put Pappa Pey Pey on the map. Each one comes with a specific set of toppings. You cannot remove items for a discount, but you can add extra toppings for a fee. The specialty pies are usually the best sellers.
- The Pey Pey Special – Pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, onions, and extra mozzarella. Small $14.99, Medium $17.49, Large $19.99, XL $22.49
- BBQ Chicken Ranch – Grilled chicken, smoky BBQ sauce, red onions, and a ranch drizzle. Small $15.49, Medium $17.99, Large $20.49, XL $22.99
- Veggie Supreme – Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, tomatoes, and red onions. Small $13.99, Medium $16.49, Large $18.99, XL $21.49
- Meat Lovers – Pepperoni, ham, bacon, sausage, and ground beef. Small $16.99, Medium $19.49, Large $21.99, XL $24.49
- Hawaiian Luau – Ham, pineapple, and bacon. Small $14.49, Medium $16.99, Large $19.49, XL $21.99
- Buffalo Chicken – Spicy buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, and a blue cheese crumble. Small $15.99, Medium $18.49, Large $20.99, XL $23.49
These prices are accurate for dine-in and takeout. Delivery fees are added separately. Some locations run a lunch special on the Small specialty pies, so ask your local store about that deal.
Build Your Own Pizza Pricing
Customization is easy. You start with a cheese pizza as your base. Then you choose from the list of standard toppings. Each topping costs the same amount, regardless of which one you pick.
- Standard Toppings (Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, tomatoes, extra cheese): $1.50 each for Small, $1.75 for Medium, $2.00 for Large, $2.25 for XL
- Premium Toppings (Grilled chicken, bacon, ham, ground beef, pineapple, feta cheese): $2.25 each for Small, $2.50 for Medium, $2.75 for Large, $3.00 for XL
If you want a gluten-free crust, there is an additional charge of $3.00 on any size. A cauliflower crust costs $4.00 extra. These alternatives are available for both classic and specialty pizzas.
Stuffed Crust And Deep Dish Options
Pappa Pey Pey also offers a stuffed crust version of any pizza. The crust is filled with a blend of mozzarella and cheddar. This upgrade adds $4.00 to the total price of the pizza. Deep dish is available for Medium and Large sizes only. The deep dish base price is $4.50 higher than the regular hand-tossed version.
You should note that deep dish takes longer to cook. Expect an extra 10 to 15 minutes of wait time if you order this style. It is worth the wait for the crispy edges and thick center.
Appetizers And Side Orders
No pizza night is complete without something to share. The sides menu is straightforward. Most items are designed for two or more people. The portions are generous, so you might end up with leftovers.
Breadsticks And Garlic Knots
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $6.49. Served with a side of marinara sauce.
- Cheesy Breadsticks (8 pieces) – $8.99. Topped with mozzarella and parmesan.
- Breadsticks with Butter (6 pieces) – $5.99. Simple and soft.
You can add a dipping sauce to any of these for $0.75. The available sauces are marinara, ranch, blue cheese, and garlic butter.
Chicken Wings And Tenders
The wings are available in orders of 6, 12, or 18 pieces. They come in three flavors: Classic Buffalo, BBQ, and Garlic Parmesan. The tenders are all white meat and come with a choice of dipping sauce.
- 6 Wings – $8.99
- 12 Wings – $15.99
- 18 Wings – $21.99
- Chicken Tenders (5 pieces) – $9.49. Served with fries.
If you want a mix of two wing flavors, you can request that at no extra cost. Just write it in the special instructions when you order online.
Salads And Soup
There are three salads on the menu. Each one is served in a large bowl. You can get them as a side portion or as a full meal.
- House Salad – Side $4.99, Full $7.49. Includes lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and croutons.
- Caesar Salad – Side $5.49, Full $7.99. Romaine, parmesan, and Caesar dressing.
- Greek Salad – Side $6.49, Full $9.49. Feta, olives, peppers, and red onions.
The soup of the day is usually a tomato basil or a chicken noodle. A cup costs $3.99 and a bowl costs $5.49. Ask your server what is available that day.
Desserts And Sweet Treats
The dessert menu is short but satisfying. These items are perfect for sharing or for a solo treat after a big meal.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (10 inch) – $7.99. Baked fresh and served warm.
- Cinnamon Sugar Breadsticks (6 pieces) – $6.99. Comes with a sweet icing dip.
- Brownie Sundae – $6.49. Warm brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and chocolate syrup.
The cookie is a crowd favorite. It takes about 15 minutes to bake, so order it at the same time as your pizza if you want it to arrive together.
Drinks And Beverages
You can order soft drinks by the glass or by the pitcher. The prices are standard for a casual dining restaurant.
- Soft Drinks (Fountain) – $2.99 per glass, free refills for dine-in.
- Pitcher of Soda – $6.99. Serves about four glasses.
- Bottled Water – $1.99
- Iced Tea – $2.99 per glass, $6.49 per pitcher.
Alcohol is available at some locations. The beer list changes by region. You can expect domestic bottles to be around $4.50 and craft drafts around $6.00. Check with your local store for availability.
Deals, Coupons, And Combo Offers
Pappa Pey Pey runs regular promotions. The most common deal is the “Pey Pey Combo” which includes a Large two-topping pizza, 12 wings, and a pitcher of soda. This combo is priced at $29.99. That is a significant savings compared to ordering the items separately.
There is also a lunch special on weekdays from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM. You can get a personal size pizza (8 inches) with one topping and a side salad for $8.99. This is only available for dine-in or takeout, not delivery.
If you order online through the official website, you can often find a “Welcome Back” coupon for 15% off your first order. Sign up for the email newsletter to receive that discount code. Some locations also offer a student discount of 10% with a valid student ID.
How To Save Money On Your Order
Here are some practical tips to keep your total lower.
- Order the Large size instead of two Mediums. The price per square inch is much better.
- Stick to the classic cheese or pepperoni if you want the cheapest option.
- Use the lunch special if you are eating alone or with one other person.
- Look for the weekly email coupon before you place an online order.
- Skip the delivery and choose takeout. You save the delivery fee and the driver tip.
These small choices can save you anywhere from five to fifteen dollars on a typical order.
Delivery, Takeout, And Online Ordering
You can place your order through the phone, the website, or the mobile app. The online system is easy to use. You select your items, choose your pickup or delivery time, and pay with a card or cash (for takeout only).
Delivery fees vary by distance. The standard fee is $2.99 within a three-mile radius. Beyond that, the fee increases by about $0.50 per mile. There is no minimum order for delivery, but a $1.00 small order fee applies to orders under $10.00.
Most orders are ready in 20 to 30 minutes for takeout. Delivery usually takes 30 to 45 minutes depending on traffic and how busy the store is. You can track your delivery driver in real time using the app.
Nutritional Information And Allergens
If you have dietary restrictions, you can request a full allergen menu at the counter. The staff are trained to answer questions about ingredients. The gluten-free crust is prepared in a separate area to reduce cross contamination, but the kitchen is not entirely gluten-free.
For calorie counts, a single slice of the Large Cheese Pizza contains approximately 280 calories. A slice of the Meat Lovers has around 410 calories. The garlic knots are about 150 calories per piece. These numbers are estimates and can vary slightly by location.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Does the Pappa Pey Pey Pizza menu with prices change by location?
A: Yes, prices can vary slightly depending on the franchise owner and local cost of living. The differences are usually less than one dollar per item. You can check the online menu for your specific store by entering your zip code on the website.
Q: Are there any vegetarian options on the menu?
A: Yes. The Veggie Supreme is fully vegetarian. You can also build your own pizza with any combination of vegetable toppings. The cheese pizza is always a safe bet for vegetarians.
Q: What is the price difference between hand-tossed and thin crust?
A: There is no price difference. The thin crust is the same cost as the regular hand-tossed dough. You can choose your crust style for free when you place your order.
Q: Can I use multiple coupons on one order?
A: No, only one coupon or promotional offer can be applied per order. You cannot stack a percentage discount with a combo deal. Choose the option that gives you the best value for your specific order.
Q: Do they offer a military discount?
A: Some locations do offer a 10% military discount with a valid ID. This is not a corporate-wide policy. You should call your local store to ask if they participate in this program.
Final Thoughts On The Menu Pricing
The Pappa Pey Pey Pizza menu with prices is competitive for the quality of food you recieve. The portions are large, and the ingredients taste fresh. The specialty pies are where the value really shines, especially if you catch a combo deal.
Before you go, remember to check the current weekly special. The menu is simple enough to navigate, but the pricing structure can be confusing if you want to add a lot of toppings. Use the breakdown above to calculate your total before you reach the checkout screen.
We hope this guide makes your next order a smooth one. Go ahead and try the Pey Pey Special if you are feeling hungry. It is the most popular pie on the menu for a reason. Enjoy your meal.