Wood-fired pies and specialty toppings set Fat Pie Pizza apart, and the menu prices reveal how affordable a custom pizza night can be. If you want the full Fat Pie Pizza Menu with Prices before you order, this guide breaks down the pies, sides, and drinks so you know what to expect.
Fat Pie Pizza keeps things simple. You pick a size, pick a style, and pay a fair price for fresh dough and real toppings.
Fat Pie Pizza Menu With Prices
Prices vary a little by location, but most shops stay close to the numbers below. Use this as your rough guide.
Signature Pies And What They Cost
- Cheese Pie, 12 inch: $13.50
- Cheese Pie, 16 inch: $17.00
- Pepperoni Classic, 12 inch: $15.00
- Pepperoni Classic, 16 inch: $19.00
- Fat Pie Supreme, 16 inch: $23.50
- Meat Lovers, 16 inch: $24.00
- Veggie Garden, 16 inch: $21.00
- White Garlic Pie, 16 inch: $22.00
- Buffalo Chicken Pie, 16 inch: $23.00
Small pies run about $2 to $4 less then the large. A slice is often sold at lunch for $3.50 to $4.50.
Build Your Own Pizza Prices
Custom pies are where Fat Pie Pizza shines. Start with a base and add what you like.
- Choose your size: 12 inch or 16 inch.
- Pick a base: red sauce, white sauce, or olive oil.
- Add cheese: mozzarella is included, vegan cheese costs $2.00 more.
- Add toppings: $1.50 each for veggies, $2.00 for meats.
Premium toppings like prosciutto or roasted garlic cost $2.50. Most custom pies land between $16 and $25.
Sides, Salads, And Drinks
- Garlic Knots (6): $5.50
- Cheesy Bread: $7.00
- Mozzarella Sticks (5): $7.50
- Caesar Salad: $8.00
- House Salad: $7.50
- Chicken Wings (8): $11.00
- Fountain Drink: $2.50
- Canned Soda: $2.00
- Bottled Water: $1.75
Combos And Family Deals
You can save real money with a combo. These deals are popular for a reason.
- Two 16 inch pies plus garlic knots: $42.00
- Large pie, wings, and two drinks: $34.00
- Family pack, two large pies and a salad: $46.00
- Lunch slice and a drink: $6.00
Deals change by day. Call your local shop or check the app before you order.
How To Order And Save Money
A few small moves keep your total low without cutting the fun.
- Order the lunch special if you eat before 3 pm.
- Split a 16 inch pie between two people instead of buying two smalls.
- Skip delivery fees and pick up your order yourself.
- Join the rewards program for a free pie after ten orders.
- Watch for Tuesday and Sunday deals on social media.
Tax and tip are not in the prices above. Delivery usually adds $3 to $5, and some shops charge a small service fee.
What Makes The Prices Worth It
Fat Pie Pizza uses fresh dough made daily. The oven runs hot, so pies cook fast and come out crisp.
Toppings are cut in house. That means better taste and less grease then many chain pies at the same price.
If you compare a large Fat Pie Supreme at $23.50 to other shops, it sits right in the middle. The quality pushes it ahead.
Final Word On The Menu
A custom pizza night at Fat Pie Pizza can cost under $30 for two people. That is hard to beat.
Check your local menu for the exact numbers, since a few items differ by store. Then order what you like and enjoy a hot pie at a fair price.