Looking at the Old Chicago menu with prices is the first step to planning a solid meal, but it is not just about picking a random pizza. You need a strategy to get the best value for your money. Old Chicago’s tavern-style thin crust might be cheaper per pie than their stuffed version, making the menu a study in pizza economics. This guide breaks down the full price list, highlights the best deals, and helps you decide what to order without blowing your budget.
Old Chicago Menu With Prices
Old Chicago is famous for its deep-dish and thin-crust pizzas, but they also serve a lot more than just pie. From appetizers to salads, calzones, and desserts, the menu covers all the bases. The prices vary depending on your location, but the figures below reflect the standard national averages. You should always check your local store for exact numbers, but this gives you a solid baseline.
Appetizers And Starters
You cannot start a meal without looking at the starters. These are perfect for sharing, or for eating alone if you are really hungry. The portions are generous, so keep that in mind before you order a full pizza.
- Boneless Wings (8 pc): $9.99 – Served with your choice of sauce, from mild to scorchin’ hot.
- Traditional Wings (8 pc): $10.49 – Crispy fried, tossed in sauce, served with celery and ranch.
- Loaded Nachos: $10.99 – Tortilla chips covered in cheese, jalapenos, black olives, and pico de gallo. You can add chicken for an extra $2.50.
- Spinach & Artichoke Dip: $8.79 – Served hot with tortilla chips for dipping.
- Italian Nachos: $11.29 – This is a fan favorite. Crispy wonton chips topped with Italian sausage, pepperoni, and cheese.
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pc): $7.99 – Classic fried cheese with marinara sauce.
- Chicago Sampler: $13.99 – A mix of boneless wings, mozzarella sticks, and Italian nachos. Great for a group.
Old Chicago Specialty Pizzas
This is the main event. Old Chicago offers three crust styles: Original Thin Crust, Hand-Tossed, and the famous Chicago Stuffed. The stuffed pizza takes longer to cook, usually 30-45 minutes, so plan ahead. The prices below are for a medium (12-inch) pizza.
Thin Crust Vs. Stuffed Pricing
The thin crust is the value play. It is crispy, holds toppings well, and costs less. The stuffed pizza is a meal in itself, but it comes with a higher price tag. Here is how the pricing breaks down for signature pies.
- Chicago Seven (Stuffed): $19.99 – Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella.
- Chicago Seven (Thin): $16.49 – Same toppings, lighter crust, lower price.
- Meat Me (Stuffed): $21.49 – Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, and ground beef.
- Meat Me (Thin): $17.99 – All the meat, none of the extra dough weight.
- Thai Chicken (Thin): $17.49 – A unique twist with chicken, carrots, cilantro, and a spicy peanut sauce.
- BBQ Chicken (Hand-Tossed): $17.99 – Smoky BBQ sauce base, grilled chicken, red onions, and cheddar.
- Veggie (Thin): $15.99 – Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and black olives.
- Buffalo Chicken (Thin): $17.49 – Diced chicken tossed in buffalo sauce with ranch drizzle.
Build Your Own Pizza Prices
If you want to customize, you can build your own pie. This is often the best route if you have picky eaters. The base price includes the crust and cheese, then you pay per topping.
- Choose your size: Small (10″) is $8.99, Medium (12″) is $10.99, Large (14″) is $13.49.
- Choose your crust: Thin and Hand-Tossed are the same price. Stuffed crust adds $4.00 to the base price.
- Add toppings: Standard toppings (pepperoni, mushrooms, onions) are $1.25 each on small, $1.75 on medium, and $2.25 on large.
- Premium toppings: Items like chicken, bacon, or Italian sausage cost $2.00 (small), $2.75 (medium), and $3.25 (large).
Pro tip: The stuffed pizza base price is higher because it includes a layer of cheese and a top crust. If you want value, stick to the thin crust and load up on veggies, which are cheaper than meats.
Calzones And Stromboli
These are like folded pizzas, and they are a great mid-point between a slice and a full pie. They come with a side of marinara for dipping.
- Pepperoni Calzone: $10.99 – Stuffed with pepperoni and a blend of mozzarella and ricotta.
- Sausage Stromboli: $11.49 – Italian sausage, peppers, onions, and cheese.
- Chicken & Bacon Calzone: $12.49 – A rich option with creamy garlic sauce.
Salads And Soups
If you want something lighter, the salads are fresh and large. You can also get a cup of soup to start.
- House Salad: $6.99 – Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and croutons.
- Caesar Salad: $7.49 – Romaine, parmesan, and Caesar dressing.
- Chicken Cobb Salad: $10.99 – Grilled chicken, bacon, egg, avocado, and blue cheese.
- Italian Chopped Salad: $9.99 – Salami, pepperoni, provolone, and garbanzo beans.
- Soup of the Day (Cup): $3.99 – Usually a hearty option like chicken noodle or tomato basil.
Sandwiches And Burgers
Old Chicago is not just pizza. They have a solid lineup of burgers and sandwiches that are often overlooked. These are cheaper than pizzas and come with fries or chips.
- Classic Cheeseburger: $10.49 – Half-pound beef patty with American cheese.
- BBQ Bacon Burger: $11.99 – Topped with crispy bacon, cheddar, and onion rings.
- Italian Sub: $10.29 – Ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone with oil and vinegar.
- Philly Cheesesteak: $11.49 – Shaved steak, peppers, onions, and melted provolone.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich: $10.99 – Grilled chicken breast with ranch and bacon on a hoagie.
Pasta Dishes
You can get a decent pasta plate here too. They are served with garlic bread. The portions are big enough for leftovers.
- Spaghetti with Meatballs: $11.99 – Classic red sauce with two large meatballs.
- Chicken Alfredo: $12.99 – Fettuccine tossed in a creamy parmesan sauce.
- Baked Ziti: $10.99 – Pasta baked with marinara and mozzarella.
- Lasagna: $12.49 – Layered with ground beef and ricotta.
Desserts
Do not skip dessert. The portions are shareable, and the prices are reasonable.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet: $6.99 – A warm cookie baked in a skillet, topped with vanilla ice cream.
- Brownie Sundae: $6.49 – Fudgy brownie with ice cream and hot fudge.
- Tiramisu: $5.99 – Classic Italian coffee-flavored dessert.
Drinks And Beverages
Old Chicago is known for its beer selection. They have over 100 varieties, including local craft brews. Soft drinks are standard price.
- Soft Drinks (Refillable): $2.99
- Craft Beer (Pint): $5.50 – $8.00 depending on the brew.
- House Wine (Glass): $6.50
- Moscow Mule: $7.99 – A signature cocktail.
Lunch Specials And Deals
If you are visiting during the week, look for the lunch menu. It is active from 11 AM to 3 PM Monday through Friday. You can get a personal pizza, a small salad, and a drink for around $8.99. This is the best value on the menu.
- Personal Thin Crust Pizza + Salad: $8.99
- Half Sandwich + Cup of Soup: $7.99
- Slice of Pizza + Salad: $7.49
They also have a happy hour from 3 PM to 6 PM with discounted appetizers and drinks. Check with your local store for specific times.
Gluten Sensitive Options
For those who avoid gluten, Old Chicago offers a gluten-sensitive crust. It is a thin, crispy crust that is prepared separately to avoid cross-contamination. The price is a bit higher.
- Gluten-Sensitive Crust (Any Size): Add $2.50 to the base pizza price.
- Gluten-Sensitive Pasta: $11.99 – Available with marinara or alfredo.
Note that the gluten-sensitive crust is smaller than the regular crust. It is about a 10-inch pie, so keep that in mind if you are very hungry.
How To Save Money On Your Order
You can always find a way to cut costs. Here are some practical steps to reduce your total bill.
- Use the app: Old Chicago has a loyalty program called “Chicago’s Best.” You earn points for every dollar spent. Sign up before you order to get a free appetizer on your birthday.
- Check for coupons: They often run online coupons for 20% off your entire order or a free dessert with a large pizza purchase.
- Order thin crust: As mentioned, it is cheaper than stuffed or hand-tossed. The hand-tossed is actually the same price as thin, but the stuffed is the premium upcharge.
- Skip the appetizer: The pizza is filling. If you order a salad and a pizza, you will have leftovers for lunch tomorrow.
- Go for lunch: The lunch specials are almost half the price of the dinner menu items.
- Share a large: A large 14-inch pizza has eight slices. Two people can easily split it, and it is cheaper than buying two personal pizzas.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the cheapest item on the Old Chicago menu?
A: The cheapest items are the side salads and the soup of the day. The cup of soup is around $3.99, and the house salad is $6.99. If you want a full meal, the lunch specials are the best deal.
Q: Does Old Chicago have a secret menu?
A: Not officially, but you can ask for “The Chicagoan.” It is a stuffed pizza with every meat topping they have. It is not listed, but they will make it if you ask. Be prepared for a high price, usually over $25.
Q: Are the prices on the Old Chicago menu with prices the same everywhere?
A: No. Franchise locations set their own prices. Urban areas and airports will have higher prices than suburban locations. The menu items are the same, but the numbers vary by a few dollars.
Q: Is the stuffed pizza worth the extra cost?
A: It depends on your appetite. The stuffed pizza is very dense and filling. One slice is like eating two slices of thin crust. If you are sharing among three or four people, it is worth it. If you are eating alone, the thin crust is a better value.
Q: Can I get a gluten-free pizza at Old Chicago?
A: Yes, they offer a gluten-sensitive crust. It costs about $2.50 more than the regular crust. The size is smaller, so you might need to order a large to get the same amount of food as a medium regular crust.
When you look at the full Old Chicago menu with prices, the strategy becomes clear. The appetizers are tempting, but they will fill you up before the main course. The best approach is to decide on your crust first, then pick your toppings. If you want to save money, go thin crust, stick to standard toppings, and visit during lunch hours. The food is consistent, the service is usually fast, and the beer selection is excellent. Just remember to bring your appetite because the portions are not small. Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, you now have the price knowledge to order like a pro.