Ice cream scoops at Oberweis carry premium prices because the milk comes from their own family farms. If you are looking for the full Oberweis Dairy Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every category, from classic sundaes to their famous glass-bottled milk, so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in.
Oberweis has been around since 1927. They control the whole process, from the cow to the cone. That is why their prices sit a little higher than the grocery store brands. You are paying for freshness, quality, and a consistent taste that has not changed in nearly a century.
Below, you will find a complete breakdown of current menu items. We have organized this by category to make it easy to scan. Keep in mind that prices can vary slightly depending on your location and local taxes. However, these figures are accurate as of the latest corporate menu release.
Oberweis Dairy Menu With Prices
This is your complete reference point. The menu is split into ice cream scoops, shakes, malts, sundaes, and their retail grocery items. We will also cover the seasonal specials that pop up throughout the year, because those often offer the best value.
Ice Cream Scoops And Cones
The core of the business is the hand-dipped ice cream. You can order a single scoop or a double. They use fresh, premium ingredients, and the butterfat content is higher than standard commercial ice cream. This makes the texture denser and the flavor richer.
- Single Scoop (Cup or Cone): $4.29
- Double Scoop (Cup or Cone): $6.49
- Kid’s Scoop: $2.99 (available for children under 10)
- Waffle Cone Upgrade: +$0.75
- Extra Toppings (Sprinkles, Nuts, Cherry): +$0.50 each
They rotate about 20 flavors at any given time. The staples like Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, and Strawberry are always available. But you will also find rotating options like Butter Pecan, Mint Chocolate Chip, and their famous Black Cherry.
Shakes And Malts
Oberweis shakes are thick. They are blended with real ice cream and whole milk, not a powdered mix. You can choose from a list of standard flavors or create your own by picking any scoop flavor available that day.
- Regular Shake (16 oz): $6.99
- Large Shake (22 oz): $8.49
- Regular Malt (16 oz): $7.29
- Large Malt (22 oz): $8.79
- Add a Shot of Syrup (Caramel, Fudge, Strawberry): +$0.60
If you want a protein boost, they offer a “Power Shake” option. This adds a scoop of protein powder to any shake for an additional $1.50. It is a popular choice for athletes who stop by after a workout.
Sundaes And Splits
These are the indulgent options. They come in a bowl with whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry on top. The Hot Fudge Sundae is the bestseller, but the Caramel Cashew is a close second.
- Hot Fudge Sundae: $6.29
- Caramel Sundae: $6.29
- Strawberry Sundae: $6.29
- Banana Split: $8.99
- Brownie Sundae: $7.49
- Extra Scoop on any Sundae: +$2.00
All sundaes are served with your choice of ice cream flavor. The default is Vanilla Bean, but you can swap it for Chocolate or any other flavor without an upcharge. That is a nice perk that many customers do not know about.
Ice Cream Cakes And Pies
If you are celebrating a birthday or an event, Oberweis makes custom ice cream cakes. These are not the dry, crumbly cakes you get at the supermarket. They use a dense ice cream base with a cookie crumb layer in the middle.
- 6-inch Round Cake (Serves 6-8): $21.99
- 8-inch Round Cake (Serves 10-12): $29.99
- Quarter Sheet Cake (Serves 12-15): $39.99
- Half Sheet Cake (Serves 20-24): $54.99
- Ice Cream Pie (8-inch): $18.99
You can order these in-store or online. They require at least 24 hours notice for custom writing. If you need one same-day, they usually have a few pre-made options in the freezer case, but the selection is limited.
Retail Grocery Items
Oberweis is not just a scoop shop. They are also a dairy brand. You can buy their products in glass bottles to take home. The glass bottles are returnable, which is a nod to their old-school approach.
- Whole Milk (Half Gallon): $4.49
- 2% Reduced Fat Milk (Half Gallon): $4.49
- Chocolate Milk (Half Gallon): $5.29
- Strawberry Milk (Half Gallon): $5.29
- Eggnog (Seasonal, Half Gallon): $5.99
- Ice Cream To-Go (Pint): $6.99
- Ice Cream To-Go (Quart): $10.99
They also sell heavy cream, half and half, and butter. The butter is made from their own cream and has a distinct yellow color. It is a favorite among local bakers.
Food Items And Snacks
Many locations have expanded their menu to include light food options. This is not a full restaurant, but they offer a few grab-and-go items that pair well with ice cream.
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich: $5.99
- Tomato Soup (Cup): $3.99
- Soup and Grilled Cheese Combo: $8.49
- Hot Dog: $4.29
- Soft Pretzel with Cheese: $4.99
These items are simple. They are not gourmet, but they are consistent. The grilled cheese uses their own cheddar cheese, which makes a noticeable difference in taste.
Seasonal And Limited Time Offerings
Oberweis rotates seasonal flavors every few months. This keeps the menu fresh. You will often find Pumpkin Pie in the fall, Peppermint Bark in the winter, and Lemon Custard in the summer.
These seasonal flavors are usually the same price as the regular scoops. However, they are only available for a short window. If you see a flavor you like, it is best to get it quickly because they often sell out.
During the summer, they also offer a “Flavor of the Month” at a slight discount. This is a marketing tactic to get people to try new things. The price is usually $3.99 for a single scoop, which is about 30 cents cheaper than the standard price.
How To Save Money On Your Order
Oberweis is not cheap. A family of four can easily spend $25 on a simple outing. However, there are a few ways to reduce the cost without giving up quality.
- Download the App: They have a loyalty program that gives you a free scoop after you spend $50. You also get exclusive coupons that are not available in-store.
- Look for the Flavor of the Month: As mentioned above, this is always discounted. It is a good way to try something new without paying full price.
- Skip the Waffle Cone: The cake cone is free. The waffle cone costs extra and does not add any ice cream.
- Share a Large Shake: The large shake is 22 ounces. It is easily enough for two people to share, especially if you have already eaten a meal.
- Buy the Pint on Sale: Grocery stores often put Oberweis pints on sale for $4.99. This is significantly cheaper than buying a scoop at the shop, and you get more ice cream.
These tips are practical. They do not require clipping coupons or jumping through hoops. Just a little bit of planning can save you a few dollars.
Comparing Prices To Competitors
How does Oberweis stack up against other premium ice cream shops? Let us look at a quick comparison. Culver’s sells a single scoop for about $3.79. Cold Stone Creamery charges around $5.49 for a “Like It” size. Baskin-Robbins is usually around $3.99 for a single scoop.
Oberweis sits right in the middle of this range. They are not the cheapest, but they are not the most expensive either. The value proposition is the quality of the milk. Because they own the farms, they control the feed and the processing. This results in a creamier product that has a shorter ingredient list.
Most of their ice cream contains only milk, cream, sugar, and natural flavorings. There are no artificial stabilizers or gums. If you read the label on a competitor’s product, you will often see carrageenan or guar gum listed. Oberweis does not use those.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions about the menu and pricing. We have answered them directly to save you time.
Does Oberweis Offer A Discount For Kids?
Yes. The Kid’s Scoop is $2.99. It is smaller than the regular single scoop, but it is perfect for young children. You do not need to ask for it; just request the kid’s size at the counter.
Can I Order A Custom Ice Cream Cake Online?
Yes. You can go to their website and use the cake builder tool. You pick the size, the flavor, and the message. You can also schedule a pickup time. The online price is the same as in-store.
Are There Any Low-Fat Or No-Sugar-Added Options?
Yes. They usually have a sherbet and a no-sugar-added vanilla or chocolate. These are made with Splenda instead of sugar. The price is the same as the regular ice cream.
Why Is The Milk More Expensive Than The Grocery Store?
Because it is not ultra-pasteurized. Standard grocery store milk is heated to a very high temperature to extend shelf life. Oberweis uses a lower pasteurization temperature, which preserves more of the natural flavor. The trade-off is a shorter shelf life, which is why it costs more.
Does The Price Include Tax?
No. The prices listed above are pre-tax. Depending on your state and local municipality, you may see an additional sales tax of 6% to 10% added at the register.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The Oberweis Dairy Menu with Prices is straightforward. You are paying for a premium product that is made with a shorter supply chain. The taste is consistent, and the ingredients are clean.
If you are on a budget, stick to the single scoop or the Flavor of the Month. If you are celebrating, the ice cream cake is worth the splurge. Either way, you are getting a product that is made from milk that comes from cows raised on family farms, not factory operations.
Before you go, check their website for the current flavor list. The menu changes frequently, and you do not want to miss out on a limited batch. Also, remember to bring back your glass bottles for a small deposit refund. It is good for the environment and good for your wallet.
That is the complete breakdown. Now you can walk in with confidence, knowing exactly what you want and what it will cost. Enjoy your scoop.