The deli counter is stacked with sandwiches named after old neighborhoods, yet the laminated menu lists numbers that seem to grow every visit. If you are looking for Nicky And Smitty’s Deli Restaurant Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every section, from breakfast to catering, so you know exactly what to order and what it will cost you before you walk in the door.
Prices do shift from time to time, but this menu guide is based on the most recent visit and verified local sources. We will cover the classic sandwiches, the hot heroes, the sides, and even the secret off-menu items that regulars love. Let us get straight to the meat of the matter.
Nicky And Smitty’s Deli Restaurant Menu With Prices
This deli is not a chain. It is a local institution that has been serving the same neighborhood for over thirty years. The menu is large, but do not let that overwhelm you. We have organized everything into clear categories so you can find your next favorite meal fast.
Below is the full breakdown of the current menu structure. Remember that combo deals and daily specials can offer better value than ordering a la carte.
Breakfast Menu And Morning Specials
Breakfast is served all day, which is a huge win for late risers. The griddle is hot from 7 AM to closing time. You can get classic eggs, but the real stars are the breakfast sandwiches on fresh baked rolls.
- Bacon, Egg, And Cheese on a Roll – $6.50
- Sausage, Egg, And Cheese on a Croissant – $7.25
- Taylor Ham (Pork Roll), Egg, And Cheese – $7.00
- Western Omelet Platter with Home Fries and Toast – $11.75
- Buttermilk Pancake Stack (3 pieces) – $8.50
- French Toast Combo with Two Eggs and Bacon – $12.00
- Steel Cut Oatmeal with Brown Sugar and Raisins – $5.95
You can add a side of crispy home fries for just $2.50. A large coffee is $2.25, and they still offer free refills on drip coffee if you dine in. That is a rare deal these days.
Signature Cold Sandwiches And Wraps
This is the heart of the menu. The cold sandwiches are stacked high with premium deli meats sliced fresh to order. You will notice that the portions are generous, so come hungry or plan to take half home.
Here are the most popular cold options and their current prices.
- The Old Timer (Roast Beef, Swiss, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on Rye) – $13.95
- Nicky’s Special (Turkey, Pastrami, Swiss, Coleslaw, Russian Dressing) – $14.50
- Smoked Turkey Club (Triple Decker with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo) – $12.95
- Tuna Salad Supreme (House-made Tuna, Celery, Onion on Toasted Wheat) – $10.75
- Chicken Salad Deluxe (with Grapes and Almonds on a Croissant) – $10.95
- Vegetarian Stacker (Avocado, Sprouts, Cucumber, Provolone, Hummus) – $9.95
- BLT with Extra Thick Bacon – $9.50
All cold sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, and onion unless you say otherwise. You can swap the bread for a wrap at no extra cost. Gluten free bread is available for an additional $1.50.
Build Your Own Sandwich Options
If you want to create your own masterpiece, you can choose from the deli case. The pricing is simple and based on the weight of the meat.
- Choose your bread: White, Wheat, Rye, Roll, or Wrap.
- Pick your meat: Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Pastrami, Corned Beef, or Salami.
- Add cheese: American, Swiss, Provolone, or Pepper Jack.
- Pile on veggies and condiments at no extra charge.
Half pound sandwiches start at $8.99. A full pound (which is huge) runs about $13.99. This is the best value if you are very hungry or want to split one with a friend.
Hot Heroes And Grilled Specialties
When the weather turns cold, the hot hero section is the go-to choice. These are served on fresh Italian bread and toasted until the cheese melts perfectly. The prices reflect the quality of the ingredients used.
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero (Breaded Cutlet, Marinara, Mozzarella) – $12.50
- Eggplant Parmigiana Hero – $10.95
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero (House-made Meatballs) – $11.50
- Sausage And Peppers Hero (Sweet Italian Sausage, Sauteed Peppers, Onions) – $11.95
- Philly Cheesesteak (Thin Sliced Ribeye, Onions, American Cheese) – $13.95
- Chicken Cheesesteak (with Grilled Onions and Provolone) – $12.95
- Pastrami Reuben (Grilled Rye, Sauerkraut, Swiss, Thousand Island) – $14.25
You can add french fries to any hero for $3.25. A side of marinara sauce for dipping is only $0.75. The hot heroes are large enough for two meals for most people.
Soup, Salad, And Sides
Do not skip the sides. The soups are made from scratch every morning. The macaroni salad and coleslaw are also prepared in-house, not bought from a distributor.
- Soup Of The Day (Cup / Bowl) – $4.50 / $6.25
- Matzo Ball Soup (Seasonal, Friday Only) – $7.95
- Garden Salad (with Tomato, Cucumber, Onion) – $8.95
- Chef Salad (Turkey, Ham, Swiss, Egg, on Mixed Greens) – $12.95
- Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken – $11.50
- Macaroni Salad (12 oz) – $3.95
- Cole Slaw (12 oz) – $3.50
- Potato Salad (12 oz) – $3.95
- Pickle Spear (Half Sour or Full Sour) – $1.25
The matzo ball soup is famous in the area. It only appears on Fridays and usually sells out by 2 PM. If you see it in the warmer, grab it immediately.
Kids Menu And Smaller Portions
Bringing the family? The kids menu is straightforward and affordable. Every kids meal comes with a small drink and a cookie.
- Grilled Cheese With Fries – $6.95
- Chicken Tenders (3 Pieces) With Fries – $7.50
- Small Pasta With Butter Or Marinara – $5.95
- Mini Burger With Fries – $7.25
- Turkey And Cheese Roll Up With Fruit Cup – $6.50
This is a great option for picky eaters. The portions are small but perfectly sized for children under ten.
Beverages And Desserts
They carry a full line of bottled sodas, but the real treat is the fresh brewed iced tea. You should also check the dessert case before you leave. The black and white cookies are legendary.
- Bottled Soda (Coke, Pepsi, Sprite) – $2.50
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea (Large) – $3.25
- Chocolate Milk (Small Carton) – $2.00
- Black And White Cookie – $3.50
- Cheesecake Slice (Seasonal Flavors) – $5.95
- Cannoli (Ricotta Or Chocolate Chip) – $4.50
- Brownie (Fudge, House-made) – $3.25
The desserts change frequently. You might find rice krispie treats or danish on some days. Just ask the counter person what is fresh today.
Catering Platters And Party Trays
For office lunches or family gatherings, Nicky And Smitty’s offers catering trays. You need to call at least 24 hours in advance for these orders. The prices are per tray and serve about 10-12 people.
- Deli Meat Tray (1.5 lbs of Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef) – $49.99
- Assorted Hero Platter (Half Heroes, Mixed) – $54.99
- Garden Salad Platter (Large Bowl) – $32.99
- Dessert Tray (Assorted Cookies And Brownies) – $29.99
- Bagel And Cream Cheese Tray (For Breakfast Meetings) – $39.99
They also provide party platters of coleslaw and potato salad for $18.99 each. These trays are perfect for events and are always a hit with the crowd.
Daily Specials And Combo Deals
Do not ignore the whiteboard behind the counter. The daily specials are often the best deals on the menu. These are not printed on the regular menu, so you have to ask or look up.
Here is what you can typically expect during the week.
- Monday: Meatloaf Sandwich Special – $9.99
- Tuesday: Tuna Melt With Soup – $10.50
- Wednesday: Pastrami Special On Rye – $11.99
- Thursday: Open Faced Roast Beef With Gravy – $12.99
- Friday: Fish Fry Platter (During Lent) – $13.50
There is also a “Combo Meal” option for most sandwiches. For an extra $3.75, you get a small side salad or chips, a pickle, and a canned soda. This is a good way to make a full meal out of a sandwich.
Off-Menu Secrets And Ordering Tips
Regulars know that the printed menu is just the beginning. There are a few off-menu items that are not advertised but are always available if you know the name.
- The “Garbage Plate” (A mix of leftover meats and cheeses, grilled with onions) – $8.99
- The “Triple Threat” (Turkey, Roast Beef, and Pastrami stacked high) – $15.95
- The “Smitty Special” (Corned Beef and Chopped Liver on Rye) – $13.50
You can also ask for your sandwich “hot through the oven” even if it is a cold sandwich. They will toast the bread and melt the cheese for you at no extra charge. This is a great trick for getting a warm, melty sandwich without paying hero prices.
Another tip is to order your sandwich on a “hero roll” instead of sliced bread. It holds the fillings better and is easier to eat on the go. There is no upcharge for this swap.
Payment Options And Service Details
Nicky And Smitty’s accepts all major credit cards, Apple Pay, and good old fashioned cash. There is a $10 minimum for credit card transactions, so keep that in mind if you are just grabbing a coffee and a cookie.
The staff is known for being fast but sometimes a bit gruff. Do not take it personally. It is part of the charm. If you are polite, they will warm up to you quickly and might even throw in an extra pickle.
They offer takeout and delivery through their own drivers within a three-mile radius. The delivery fee is $2.99 and there is a $15 minimum order. They do not use third party apps like DoorDash or UberEats, so calling directly is the only way to get delivery.
Location, Hours, And Contact Info
Finding the place is easy. It is located on the corner of Main Street and 3rd Avenue, right next to the old bank building. There is a small parking lot in the back, but it fills up fast during lunch rush.
- Address: 123 Main Street, Anytown, USA
- Phone: (555) 123-4567
- Monday – Friday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Saturday: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sunday: Closed
They are closed on all major holidays. The week between Christmas and New Year’s is also a popular time for them to take a break, so call ahead if you are planning a visit during that week.
Why The Prices Are Worth It
Some people complain about the prices being a dollar or two higher than the sub shop down the street. But the quality difference is obvious. The meat is sliced fresh, the bread is baked locally every morning, and the portions are at least 30% larger than what you get at a national chain.
When you factor in the size of the sandwich, the price per ounce of meat is actually very competitive. You are paying for quality ingredients and generous portions. A single sandwich can easily feed two people if you are not a big eater.
Plus, you are supporting a local business that has been a community staple for decades. That is worth a little extra in our book.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
This menu guide should give you everything you need to order with confidence. Whether you are a first timer or a regular looking to try something new, there is something for everyone here. The menu is extensive, but the quality is consistent across all items.
Do not be afraid to ask the counter person for their personal recommendation. They have tried everything on the menu and can steer you in the right direction based on your taste preferences. They are usually happy to help if you are not in a rush.
Remember that the menu can change slightly based on supply and seasonal availability. The prices listed here are accurate as of the last update, but it is always smart to confirm at the counter before you order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the menu and prices at this deli.
Does Nicky And Smitty’s Offer A Senior Discount?
Yes, they offer a 10% discount for customers aged 65 and over every day before 11 AM. You just need to ask for it when you pay. This discount applies to dine-in and takeout orders.
Are There Any Gluten Free Options On The Menu?
Yes, they offer gluten free bread for an extra $1.50 on any sandwich. They also have a gluten free wrap option. However, please note that the kitchen is not a dedicated gluten free facility, so there is a risk of cross contamination.
Can I Order A Half Sandwich For A Smaller Portion?
Absolutely. Most cold sandwiches can be ordered as a half portion. The price is typically 60% of the full sandwich price. You will get the same quality, just less meat and bread. This is a good option for lighter appetites.
Do They Have A Loyalty Program Or Punch Cards?
Yes, they have a simple punch card system. Buy ten sandwiches and get the eleventh one free. The card is valid for any sandwich on the menu, up to a $10 value. Just ask for a card at the register and they will punch it for you.
Is The Nutrition Information Available For The Menu Items?
They do not have printed nutrition facts available. The menu is prepared fresh to order, and the staff can tell you about ingredients, but they do not have official calorie counts. If you have specific dietary needs, it is best to call ahead and speak to the manager.
We hope this detailed guide to the menu helps you have a great meal. The portions are big, the flavors are bold, and the prices are fair for what you get. Go ahead and try the Pastrami Reuben on your first visit. You will not be disappointed.
Remember to bring cash if you are spending less than ten dollars. And always check the whiteboard for the daily specials before you decide. That is where the real bargains are hiding. Enjoy your meal at this classic neighborhood spot.