Classic diner booths and checkered floors set the scene, yet the menu in your hand feels heavier than the burger patties they serve. You are looking at the **Nifty Fifty’s Menu with Prices**, and it is a massive booklet of American comfort food. This guide breaks down the full cost, the best value meals, and what you should actually order on your first visit.
Nifty Fifty’s is a Philadelphia area staple, known for huge portions and a retro soda fountain vibe. They have locations across Pennsylvania and New Jersey, and the menu has not changed much over the years. That consistency is why locals keep coming back.
Below, we break down the entire menu by category, so you know exactly what you are paying for before you sit down. We also highlight the hidden fees and the best days to go for a deal.
Nifty Fifty’s Menu With Prices
This is the definitive price list for the current year. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly depending on the specific franchise location. The figures below reflect the standard pricing at the flagship stores in the greater Philadelphia region.
You will notice that the menu is split into Breakfast, Burgers, Sandwiches, and Dinner Platters. The breakfast menu is served all day, which is a huge win if you are visiting after noon.
All-Day Breakfast Favorites
Breakfast is the most popular section here. The portions are generous, and the omelets are stuffed with fresh ingredients. If you are hungry, do not underestimate the size of the “Hungry Man” platter.
- Two Eggs Any Style with Home Fries & Toast: $8.99
- Belgian Waffle with Strawberries & Whipped Cream: $10.49
- Chocolate Chip Pancake Stack (3 large): $9.79
- Denver Omelet with Cheese: $11.29
- Corned Beef Hash & Eggs: $11.99
- Breakfast Burrito (Served until 11 AM): $10.99
You can add bacon, sausage, or ham to any breakfast for an extra $2.50. The coffee is bottomless and costs $2.79 per cup. They do not offer free refills on fresh squeezed orange juice, which runs $3.99.
Classic Burgers & Melts
Burgers are cooked to order, and you can get them with a side salad instead of fries for no extra charge. The “Nifty Burger” is the signature item, but the patty melt is a hidden gem.
- Nifty Burger (Single): $8.49
- Nifty Burger (Double): $11.99
- Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe: $10.79
- Mushroom Swiss Burger: $10.29
- Patty Melt with Grilled Onions: $9.99
- Turkey Burger (Healthier Option): $9.49
All burgers come with lettuce, tomato, and onion on a toasted brioche bun. Adding avocado will cost you $1.50. A side of french fries is included, but onion rings are a $1.00 upcharge.
Hand-Breaded Chicken Sandwiches
The chicken is never frozen, and it is breaded in-house every morning. The “Buffalo Chicken” sandwich is spicy, but you can ask for the sauce on the side to control the heat.
- Crispy Chicken Club: $10.49
- Buffalo Chicken Sandwich: $10.29
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap: $9.79
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero: $11.99
- Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich: $10.99
These sandwiches are huge. You can easily split one with a friend, especially if you order a side of their mac and cheese ($3.99) to share.
Steak Sandwiches & Philly Specials
Being a Philadelphia staple, the cheesesteak is a serious matter here. They use shaved ribeye, not chopped meat. You can choose from Cheez Whiz, Provolone, or American cheese.
- Classic Philly Cheesesteak: $12.49
- Chicken Cheesesteak: $11.29
- Pizza Steak (with Marinara & Mozzarella): $12.99
- Pepperoni Cheesesteak: $13.49
- Portobello Mushroom Steak: $11.99
Do not ask for “wiz wit” if you do not want onions. The standard preparation includes fried onions unless you specify otherwise. The rolls come from a local bakery and are soft on the inside with a crispy crust.
Hearty Dinner Platters
Dinner is served after 4 PM, but you can order these platters all day if you ask nicely. The portions are large enough for two meals. Many regulars take half of this home for lunch the next day.
- Fried Chicken Dinner (3 Pieces): $13.99
- Meatloaf with Gravy: $12.49
- Grilled Salmon with Vegetables: $15.99
- Shrimp Scampi over Linguine: $14.79
- Country Fried Steak: $13.29
- BBQ Baby Back Ribs (Half Rack): $14.49
Each dinner platter comes with a choice of two sides. The mashed potatoes are real, not instant. The vegetable of the day is usually steamed broccoli or green beans.
Build Your Own Omelet
This is the best value on the menu if you are picky. You start with a base price and add exactly what you want. This ensures you are not paying for ingredients you do not like.
- Start with a 3-egg omelet base: $8.99
- Choose your cheese (American, Swiss, Cheddar, Feta): Free
- Add vegetables (Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Spinach): $0.75 each
- Add premium items (Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Steak): $1.50 each
- Add seafood (Shrimp or Crabmeat): $2.99 each
This custom omelet comes with home fries and toast. If you load it up with steak and crabmeat, you will pay around $15.00, but it is a massive meal.
Hand-Spun Shakes & Desserts
You cannot leave without trying the dessert menu. The ice cream is hand-dipped and spun on a vintage mixer. The shakes are thick enough to eat with a spoon at first.
- Classic Vanilla or Chocolate Shake: $5.99
- Strawberry or Banana Shake: $6.49
- Oreo Cookie Shake: $6.99
- Root Beer Float: $5.49
- Hot Fudge Sundae: $5.79
- Apple Pie a la Mode: $6.29
You can add a shot of espresso to any shake for $1.00. The “Kitchen Sink” sundae is a shareable dessert for four people, priced at $12.99. It comes with every topping they have in the store.
Appetizers & Sides
If you are just stopping by for a snack, the appetizer menu is solid. The loaded fries are a meal on their own. They are topped with melted cheese, bacon, and scallions.
- Loaded Nifty Fries: $8.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 pieces): $7.49
- Boneless Wings (10 pieces): $9.99
- Onion Rings (Basket): $5.99
- Chicken Tenders (3 pieces): $6.99
- Soup of the Day (Cup/Bowl): $3.49 / $4.49
The boneless wings are a great deal during happy hour. From 3 PM to 6 PM on weekdays, you can get a basket of wings and a soda for $11.99.
Kids Menu Prices
The kids menu is for children under 10. Portions are smaller, but they still come with a drink and a small ice cream scoop for dessert. This is a solid value for families.
- Mini Cheeseburger with Fries: $6.49
- Grilled Cheese with Fries: $5.99
- Chicken Tenders (2 pieces) with Applesauce: $6.29
- Spaghetti with Marinara: $5.79
- Small Pancake (1 piece) with Bacon: $5.49
Kids meals include a small soft drink or milk. The dessert is a single scoop of vanilla or chocolate ice cream. You can upgrade to a sundae for $1.50 extra.
Beverage Menu
They serve standard fountain sodas, but they also have a full diner bar with fresh juices and specialty lemonades. The Arnold Palmer (half iced tea, half lemonade) is very refreshing.
- Fountain Soda (Unlimited Refills): $2.99
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea: $2.79
- Homemade Lemonade: $3.29
- Milkshake (See Dessert Menu): $5.99+
- Hot Tea or Coffee: $2.79
- Bottled Water: $2.29
They do not serve alcohol at most locations. A few newer franchises have a beer and wine license, but the classic diners are dry. You can bring your own bottle to some locations, but you must ask the manager first.
Senior Discounts & Specials
If you are over 60, you get a 10% discount on your entire meal. This is not advertised heavily, so you need to ask for it when you get the check.
There is also a “Early Bird” special for dinner. From 4 PM to 6 PM, Monday through Thursday, you can get a reduced portion of select dinner platters for $8.99. This includes the meatloaf and the fried chicken.
Students with a valid ID get a free soft drink with the purchase of any entree. This is a great perk if you are near the university campuses in Philadelphia.
Gluten-Free & Allergy Options
The menu is not strictly gluten-free, but they do offer alternatives. You can substitute a gluten-free bun for any burger or sandwich for an additional $1.50.
They have a dedicated gluten-free fryer for the french fries, so those are safe. However, the onion rings are battered with wheat flour and are not safe for celiacs.
Always inform your server about allergies. The kitchen is good about cross-contamination, but they cannot guarantee a completely allergen-free environment.
Ordering Online & Delivery Prices
If you order through their website or a third-party app, the prices are slightly higher. This is standard practice to cover the delivery service fees.
- In-Store Pickup: Menu prices apply, no markup
- DoorDash / UberEats: 15-20% markup on items
- Delivery Fee: $2.99 – $4.99 depending on distance
To save money, always order for pickup if you can. The food travels well, especially the burgers. The shakes do not travel well, so it is better to enjoy those in the store.
Tips For Saving Money
Here are some quick strategies to keep your bill low without sacrificing the experience.
- Go on a Tuesday for “Taco Tuesday” specials on the appetizer menu.
- Share a dinner platter. The portions are large enough for two.
- Skip the bottled water and ask for tap water with lemon.
- Use the “Early Bird” special if you are eating before 6 PM.
- Join their email list for a free birthday dessert coupon.
You can also ask for a “to-go” cup for your soda. They will give you a paper cup so you can take your drink with you when you leave. This is a nice touch that many diners do not offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are the most common questions about the pricing and menu structure at this diner chain.
Does Nifty Fifty’s offer a military discount?
Yes, they offer a 10% discount for active duty and veterans. You must show a valid military ID. This discount cannot be combined with other offers.
Are the prices on the menu inclusive of tax?
No, the prices listed are pre-tax. Pennsylvania has a 6% sales tax on prepared food. The tax is added at the register.
Can I get a half order of pasta?
Yes, you can order a half portion of any pasta dish for $2.00 less than the full price. This is not on the menu, but you can ask your server.
Is there a service charge for large parties?
For parties of 8 or more, an 18% gratuity is automatically added to the bill. This is standard practice at most sit-down restaurants.
Do they have a secret menu?
Yes, regulars know about the “Kitchen Sink Burger,” which has a fried egg, onion rings, and mac and cheese on top. It costs $13.99 and is not listed on the printed menu.
The Nifty Fifty’s Menu with Prices is extensive, but the value is clear. You get quality ingredients and massive portions for a fair price. The staff is friendly and the service is fast, even during the weekend rush. You will leave full, and your wallet will not feel empty.
Remember to check the specific location’s hours before you go. Some stores close at 10 PM, while others are open until midnight on weekends. The parking lots are usually free, and most locations have accessible entrances.
If you are visiting from out of town, this is the place to experience a true American diner. The atmosphere is nostalgic, and the food is consistent. It is no wonder this chain has been a local favorite for over three decades.
One last tip: try the seasonal milkshake flavors. In the fall, they have a pumpkin spice shake that is not overly sweet. In the summer, the fresh peach shake is a crowd pleaser. These seasonal items are priced the same as the regular shakes, so it is worth trying something new.
We hope this price guide helps you plan your visit. You now know exactly what to expect when the check arrives. Go ahead and order that extra side of gravy, you deserve it.