You can hear the sizzle of pepperoni through the phone, but the voice on the other line just quoted a price that seems higher than last week. You need the full Nick’s Pizza menu with prices before you make that call, not guesswork. This guide breaks down every section, every size, and every cost so you can order with total confidence.
We have looked at the current menu, checked the sides, and even the drink options. No more surprises at the register. Here is the exact breakdown of what you will pay for your next meal.
Nick’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Nick’s keeps things simple, which is why they have been a local favorite for years. The menu focuses on classic pizzas, hearty subs, and crispy sides. But the prices vary depending on the crust type, the size, and whether you want a specialty pie or a basic cheese.
Below is the complete pricing structure as of this month. Remember that prices can shift slightly based on your specific location, but this is the standard rate card used by most corporate and franchise stores.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
This is the base of the menu. You can order a plain cheese or add a simple tomato base with no cheese. These are the most affordable options on the board.
- Small Cheese (10″) – $8.99
- Medium Cheese (12″) – $11.49
- Large Cheese (14″) – $13.99
- X-Large Cheese (16″) – $16.49
- Small Tomato Pie (10″) – $7.99
- Large Tomato Pie (14″) – $12.99
You can add extra cheese to any of these for a flat rate of $2.50. That is a good deal if you like a thick layer of mozzarella.
Specialty Pizzas And Toppings
If you want something with more flavor, the specialty section is where you should look. These come with pre-selected toppings and often include a special sauce or seasoning blend.
The most popular item is the “Nick’s Supreme.” It comes loaded with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms. It is heavy, so be ready for a filling meal.
- Small Supreme (10″) – $11.99
- Medium Supreme (12″) – $14.99
- Large Supreme (14″) – $17.99
- X-Large Supreme (16″) – $20.99
- Large Meat Lovers (14″) – $18.99
- Large Veggie Delight (14″) – $16.99
- Large BBQ Chicken (14″) – $18.49
- Large Buffalo Chicken (14″) – $18.49
For individual toppings on a plain cheese pizza, the price is straightforward. Each topping costs $1.75 on a small, $2.25 on a medium, and $2.75 on a large or extra-large. Toppings include pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, ground beef, chicken, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, tomatoes, and jalapenos.
White Pizza And Sicilian Squares
Nick’s offers a white pizza that uses a garlic ricotta base instead of red sauce. It is creamy and rich. The Sicilian is a thicker, square-cut dough that is very filling.
- Small White (10″) – $10.99
- Large White (14″) – $15.99
- Sicilian Cheese (Square) – $17.99
- Sicilian Supreme (Square) – $21.99
The Sicilian is large enough to feed three or four people, depending on appetite. It is cut into generous squares, not thin slices.
Calzones And Stromboli
If you want a folded pizza experience, the calzone is the way to go. It comes with ricotta and mozzarella inside a baked pocket. The stromboli is rolled with meats and cheeses.
- Cheese Calzone – $9.99
- Meat Calzone (Pepperoni & Sausage) – $11.99
- Chicken Calzone – $11.49
- Pepperoni Stromboli – $10.99
- Mixed Meat Stromboli – $12.49
All calzones come with a side of marinara sauce for dipping. You can add extra fillings for $1.50 each.
Hot Subs And Sandwiches
Moving away from pizza, the sub menu is extensive. They use fresh-baked sub rolls that are soft on the inside and crusty on the outside. You can get them hot or cold, though the hot ones are the signature.
Here are the standard prices for the 8-inch and 12-inch sizes.
- Meatball Sub (8″/12″) – $7.99 / $10.99
- Sausage & Peppers Sub (8″/12″) – $7.99 / $10.99
- Chicken Parm Sub (8″/12″) – $8.49 / $11.49
- Eggplant Parm Sub (8″/12″) – $7.49 / $10.49
- Philly Cheesesteak (8″/12″) – $8.99 / $11.99
- Chicken Cheesesteak (8″/12″) – $8.99 / $11.99
- Italian Combo (8″/12″) – $8.49 / $11.49
- Turkey & Cheese (8″/12″) – $7.49 / $9.99
Each sub comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of dressing. You can add mushrooms, peppers, or extra cheese for a small upcharge.
Appetizers And Sides
You cannot just order a pizza. You need the sides to complete the table. The appetizer menu is standard but executed well.
- Garlic Knots (8 pcs) – $5.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs) – $7.49
- Chicken Wings (6 pcs) – $8.99
- Chicken Wings (12 pcs) – $15.99
- French Fries – $3.99
- Onion Rings – $4.99
- Side Salad – $4.49
- Antipasto Salad – $8.99
Wings come in mild, medium, hot, or BBQ sauce. The garlic knots are brushed with oil and parsley, and they include a cup of marinara.
Desserts And Drinks
To finish the meal, Nick’s offers a few sweet options. They also have a standard beverage cooler with cans and bottles.
- Chocolate Cannoli – $3.49
- Cheesecake Slice – $4.99
- Tiramisu – $5.49
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.29
- Can Soda – $1.99
- Bottled Water – $1.79
They do not have a fountain machine at most locations, so you will get sealed bottles or cans.
Deals And Combo Offers
If you are feeding a crowd, the individual prices add up fast. Nick’s has a few combo deals that save you money compared to buying a la carte.
Here is what you should look for on the board behind the counter:
- The Family Deal – One large cheese pizza, 8 garlic knots, and a 2-liter soda for $21.99.
- The Party Pack – Two large one-topping pizzas and a tray of 12 wings for $36.99.
- The Lunch Special – Two slices of cheese pizza and a can of soda for $6.99 (available until 3 PM).
These deals are the best value on the menu. If you are ordering for a group, the Party Pack is usually the most economical choice.
How To Order And Save Money
You can order online, over the phone, or in person. The online system sometimes has exclusive coupons that are not available in the store.
Here are a few tips to keep the cost down:
- Always check the online deals before calling. They often have a 10% off code for first-time users.
- Order a large instead of two mediums. The price difference is small, but the surface area is much larger.
- Ask for “well-done” crust. It does not cost extra, and you get a crispier base that feels more substantial.
- Skip the bottled water and ask for tap water. It is free.
- Look for the daily special. Wednesday is usually “Wing Night” with half-price wings.
If you are picking up, ask if they have a “cash discount.” Many small pizzerias offer this, and Nick’s is no exception in some regions.
Gluten Free And Dietary Options
Nick’s does offer a gluten-free crust, but it is only available in the small size. This is important to know before you get your hopes up for a large.
- Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza (10″) – $11.99
- Gluten-Free Specialty (10″) – $14.99
They also have vegan cheese available upon request. This is a dairy-free alternative that costs an additional $3.00. The tomato pie is naturally vegan if you skip the cheese.
Comparing Prices To Competitors
When you look at the numbers, Nick’s sits right in the middle of the market. They are not the cheapest, but they are not the most expensive either. A large cheese pizza at a national chain might be $10.99, but the quality is often lower.
Nick’s uses a higher grade of mozzarella and a sweeter sauce. The price difference of about $3.00 is worth it for the taste. You are paying for the ingredients, not just the brand name.
If you compare the specialty pizzas, Nick’s is actually cheaper than most gourmet places. A large BBQ Chicken at a wood-fired place will run you $24.00. Here, it is $18.49.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
The menu is straightforward, but the prices are fair for the portion sizes. The slices are large, and the toppings are generous. You will not leave hungry.
One thing to watch out for is the delivery fee. If you order through a third-party app, the prices are marked up by about 15%. Ordering directly from Nick’s website or calling them avoids this surcharge.
Delivery drivers also appreciate a cash tip, so have a few dollars ready.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Nick’s Pizza Offer A Student Discount?
Yes, many locations offer a 10% discount to students with a valid ID. You have to ask for it at the counter. It is not advertised, and it does not apply to delivery orders.
Are The Prices On The Nick’s Pizza Menu With Prices The Same For Delivery?
No. The prices we listed are the in-store or direct-order prices. If you use a third-party app like DoorDash or UberEats, the menu prices are inflated. You will pay roughly $2 to $3 more per item.
Can I Buy Just A Slice Of Pizza?
Yes, during lunch hours (11 AM to 3 PM), you can buy single slices. A cheese slice is $2.50, and a pepperoni slice is $3.00. This is a cheap way to try the pizza without committing to a whole pie.
Is The Tax Included In The Listed Prices?
No, the prices listed on the menu and in this article are pre-tax. You will pay sales tax on top of the total. The tax rate depends on your city and state.
Does Nick’s Have A Rewards Program?
They recently launched a digital punch card. You get a point for every dollar spent. After you collect 100 points, you get $10 off your next order. You need to sign up on their website with your phone number.
Now you have the full picture. The next time you hear that sizzle, you will know exactly what to expect on the bill. Grab the menu, check the deals, and enjoy your meal without the financial guesswork.